Nancy Pearcey, a professor and author, discusses the growing hostility towards masculinity and the toxic war on men. She explores the difference between masculinity and femininity according to the Bible and addresses the changing dynamics in gender roles. Pearcey also highlights the role of marriage in taming and civilizing men and explores the differences between engaged and nominal Christian men. The chapter concludes with a focus on auditing classes and a call to action for listeners to subscribe, leave a review, and share the episode.
The negative portrayal of masculinity as toxic and harmful has led to demoralization and hostility towards men.
Men are facing various challenges in today's society, including decreased participation in higher education, high rates of unemployment, and alarming statistics in areas such as suicide and drug addiction.
It is important to recognize the inherent strengths and virtues of masculinity and encourage men to embrace their responsibilities with compassion and respect for others.
Deep dives
The Rise of Hostility Against Men and its Impact
There is a growing social acceptance of expressing hostility against men, which has caught the attention of the author. Many publications and books portray masculinity as toxic and negative. This has led to demoralization and a sense of hostility towards men. Men are being attacked and labeled as violent, promiscuous, and irresponsible. The negative messages men receive and the labeling of normal behavior as toxic have pushed some men towards the manosphere, a community that exaggerates masculinity. It is important to understand the historical context, such as the Industrial Revolution, the rise of secularization, and the impact of Darwinian evolution in shaping society's perception of masculinity.
Understanding the Challenges Faced by Men Today
Men are facing a range of challenges in today's modern world. Men's participation in higher education has decreased, with women now outnumbering men in universities. Men are dropping out of the labor force and facing unemployment levels similar to the Great Depression. The rate of male suicides, drug addiction, homelessness, and imprisonment is alarming. Men's life expectancy has even decreased while women's remains the same. These statistics highlight the need for compassion and understanding towards men, as they are struggling in various areas of life.
The Role of Marriage and the Changing Definition of Masculinity
Marriage is beneficial for both men and women, not as a means of taming men, but as an institution that promotes responsibility and growth for both partners. The idea that women civilize men can be traced back to the Industrial Revolution, when men left their homes to work in factories, separating the spheres of achievement and morality. This created a conflict between men and women, as women were seen as morally superior to men. The changing definition of masculinity, influenced by negative cultural narratives and secularization, has led to confusion and demoralization among men. It is important to recognize the inherent strengths and virtues of masculinity and encourage men to embrace their responsibilities with compassion and respect for others.
Recognizing the Original Design and Distortions of Gender Differences
The podcast discusses the importance of distinguishing between the original creation and the effects of the fall when considering gender differences. It emphasizes that the basic physical differences between men and women are part of the created order, not a product of the fall. However, it also highlights that men and women are more alike than they are different, with most psychological traits overlapping closely. The extremes are where differences are more pronounced. The podcast encourages Christians to be cautious not to overemphasize differences and to view women's distinctives as strengths rather than weaknesses. It also notes that gender differences should be discussed in positive terms, focusing on the unique abilities and experiences of women, such as their role in bearing life and caring for young children.
Two Scripts for Masculinity: The Good Man and Toxic Masculinity
The podcast explores two different scripts for masculinity. The first script, known as the 'good man' script, is based on innate knowledge of what it means to be good and incorporates qualities like duty, integrity, sacrifice, and responsibility. The second script, labeled as toxic masculinity, includes traits such as toughness, dominance, and aggression. The podcast suggests that men are often caught between these two scripts, feeling cultural pressure to live up to traits associated with toxic masculinity. However, the podcast advocates for tapping into men's inherent understanding of the good man script and affirming their innate knowledge of what it means to be good. It discusses how this aligns with Christian values and challenges the idea that Christianity imposes an alien standard on men. It also highlights the importance of emotional intelligence, honoring and respecting one's spouse, and the positive impact of engaged Christian masculinity in marriages and families.
“Kill all men.” “Talking about healthy masculinity is like talking about healthy cancer.” “So many men, so little ammunition.” Yes, these are actual headlines. How did the idea arise that masculinity is so dangerous and destructive? Is there any hope for redemption for boys and men in today’s culture? That’s what we’re diving into today when Keith sits down with Nancy Pearcey, a professor at Houston Christian University and the author of several books, including her most recent, “The Toxic War on Masculinity: How Christianity Reconciles the Sexes.” Hear her explain why the script for masculinity turned so toxic, discuss the differences between masculinity and femininity, and share some surprising research regarding Christian men. Plus, does Christianity have the power to overcome toxic behavior in men and reconcile the sexes? Listen now!
Ok, truth time... Did you like this episode? Tell us by leaving a rating or review! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 If you did, you won't want to miss what's next (so subscribe now!). And help a friend by sharing this with them. Thank you! 🙏
Plus, the conversation is just beginning! Follow us on Twitter,Facebook, and Instagram to join in on the dialogue! If you disagree with anything in this episode, we'd love to hear your thoughts here.Want to learn more about Truth Over Tribe? Visit our website and subscribe to our weekly newsletter.