A college student shares her journey grappling with trans politics and feminism at Smith College. The conversation dives into the tensions between gender identity and women’s rights, particularly from the perspective of cis women feeling sidelined. It addresses the complexities of aligning these movements and reflects on past cultural reactions. Personal stories reveal the challenges of maintaining traditional feminist values amid evolving gender concepts, exploring how they impact societal change.
The speaker reflects on her disillusionment with trans politics in feminism, noting how it often prioritizes identity over women’s shared experiences.
She highlights the silencing of dissenting voices in academic settings, emphasizing the need for a feminism that encourages open debate and diverse perspectives.
Deep dives
The Shift in Campus Activism
The speaker reflects on her experience as a college student involved in the Queers and Allies organization at Smith College, which aimed to support the admission of trans women. Initially driven by a belief in the inclusivity of gender identity politics, she later realized that the movement was rooted in sexism and harmful to the essence of women's spaces. Despite being a co-chair and actively participating in activism, she began to question the ideology she was taught, recognizing that it disregarded the shared experiences of women. This process marked a significant shift in her understanding of feminism and prompted her to critically evaluate the dynamics of the activism surrounding gender identity.
Challenge of Gender Critical Voices
As she navigated the complexities of gender politics, she encountered hostility towards those who questioned the mainstream narratives, particularly towards women labeled as TERFs (Trans-Exclusionary Radical Feminists). The organization she was part of focused on dissenting voices, and any critical view was met with backlash, often framed as a form of hatred or bigotry. The speaker emphasized how the rhetoric around TERF identification creates an environment that silences debate and encourages women to doubt their own feelings and experiences. This led to a broader realization that women's concerns within the movement were consistently marginalized in favor of a strict adherence to gender identity politics.
Identity Politics and Male Supremacy
The conversation also examined the intertwining of identity politics with male supremacy, suggesting that the current trans movement often feels entitled to define womanhood based on individual identity rather than biological realities. The speaker posited that this perspective detracts from the genuine struggles women face under patriarchy by shifting focus to discussions about identity at the expense of shared female experiences. Additionally, she critiqued the notion that identity validation should come at the cost of women's rights, arguing that this was an example of male entitlement resurfacing in contemporary activism. This recognition sparked a deeper understanding of how women in the movement could regain agency and foster solidarity against systemic oppression.
Navigating Feminism on Campus
In her current liberal arts college, the speaker faced similar challenges when engaging in feminist discourse, noting a lack of tolerance for viewpoints that diverged from accepted theories on gender identity. An example cited involved a class discussion about female experience where questioning the exclusion of trans perspectives led to being asked to take the course remotely to avoid creating discomfort among peers. This demonstrated the broader issue of how feminist thought is increasingly policed and how academic spaces may protect prevailing ideologies at the expense of open discussion. Her advice to young women includes the importance of questioning narratives, building supportive communities, and advocating for a feminism that values diverse opinions while remaining rooted in the realities of women's experiences.
WLRN's Thistle Pettersen interviewed Sarah about her experiences as a college student getting involved and grappling with trans politics on her campus.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode