610: Severass Snape (POA Chapter 7, The Boggart in The Wardrobe)
May 9, 2023
auto_awesome
The podcast discusses the contrasting teaching styles of Snape and Lupin in Hogwarts, analyzing the impact on students. They delve into Snape's treatment of students outside Slytherin, the effects of bullying vs. collaboration, and emotions elicited from Harry and Neville. Lupin's past with Snape influences his instruction to Neville, while exploring symbolism and character nuances in Harry Potter.
Snape's mistreatment of students in Potions contrasts with Lupin's supportive approach in Defense Against The Dark Arts.
Lupin's handling of Peeves hints at a possible past camaraderie, showcasing his adeptness in dealing with challenges at Hogwarts.
Snape's presence in Lupin's class exacerbates Neville's anxiety, highlighting the importance of fair and supportive teaching practices.
The Boggart lesson emphasizes student empowerment and facing fears, showcasing Lupin's nurturing teaching style and fostering resilience.
Deep dives
Boggart in the Wardrobe Class Analysis
In the session, different but starkly contrasted classroom experiences are dissected, focusing on Snape's favoritism towards Draco and mistreatment of Ron in potions, juxtaposed against Lupin's approach in Defense Against the Dark Arts. Snape's unequal treatment of students and volatile behavior contribute to an unsafe and demoralizing class atmosphere, highlighting the importance of fair and supportive teaching practices.
Encounter with Peeves and Lupin's Composure
The interaction with Peeves highlights Lupin's ability to handle challenges with ease, indicating a probable past camaraderie between them. Lupin's calm demeanor and strategic handling of Peeves' mischief add to his cool factor, showcasing his capacity to navigate unexpected situations effectively, likely stemming from his extensive experience at Hogwarts.
Snape's Intentional Presence in Lupin's Class
Snape's calculated presence in Lupin's class serves to exacerbate Neville's anxiety and undermine Lupin's authority. By inserting himself and fueling Neville's distress, Snape reveals his vindictive nature and continues his pattern of bullying behavior, emphasizing his antagonistic role in creating a toxic learning environment.
Empowering Students Through Practical Lessons
The transformative Boggart lesson emerges as a pivotal educational moment, allowing students to confront their fears and demonstrate resilience. Lupin's practical teaching approach fosters student empowerment and showcases the potential for positive growth and self-discovery in facing one's fears, highlighting the role of effective educators in nurturing confidence and overcoming challenges.
Conclusion of the Class Analysis
Overall, the podcast episode delves into the contrasting teaching styles of Snape and Lupin, emphasizing the impact of a teacher's approach on student engagement and well-being. Through detailed analysis of classroom dynamics and character interactions, the discussion illuminates the significance of fostering a supportive and inclusive learning environment to promote student success and personal development.
Lupin's Supportive Teaching Style
Lupin demonstrates a supportive teaching style by encouraging Neville to confront his fears during the Boggart lesson. He shows genuine care for his students, knowing and engaging with them individually. Lupin's approach of awarding points for participation gamifies the lesson, fostering engagement and a positive learning environment.
The Symbolism of the Boggart
The Boggart in Lupin's class serves as a metaphor for facing and overcoming fears. By transforming into their worst fears, students like Neville confront their anxieties in a supportive group setting. The process allows for indirect confrontation of fears and promotes therapeutic growth, emphasizing the value of the lesson beyond immediate teaching outcomes.
Waddiwasi! On this week’s episode, grab your wand and get ready for the best magical classroom session to date …following the WORST magical classroom session to date! We compare and contrast Snape and Lupin's teaching styles and the impact it has on the students of Hogwarts!
Main Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 7: The Boggart in The Wardrobe
7-Word Summary: Neville fears rebuke when Snape “poisons” Trevor
We compare and contrast Harry's worst class to date (Potions) with his best class to date (Defense Against The Dark Arts)
What do we make of Snape's treatment of any student that is not in Slytherin?
We analyze the effects of bullying vs. collaboration in a classroom setting
What types of emotions does Snape elicit from Harry? Neville? Hermione?
Snape The Enabler creates an unsafe learning environment for his students
Micah plays devil's advocate and rationalizes Snape's actions toward both Neville (paying attention to detail) and Hermione (listening to the teacher)
What is the world is up with the Shrinking Solution?
Do Lupin and Peeves the Poltergeist share a history?
We contrast Snape's treatment of Neville with Lupin's desire to instill confidence in him (very reminiscent of how Harry works with Neville in Order of the Phoenix)
Does Lupin's past with Snape inform his instruction to Neville about his Boggart?
Should Lupin have explained to Harry why he didn't let him have a turn at the Boggart?
Connecting The Threads includes taking a look at the non-practical nature of Harry's first class in Order of the Phoenix and a very important Boggart scene with Mrs. Weasley
Odds & Ends cover the origin of Boggarts, Draco's knowledge of Sirius Black, Hermione's secret, rat references and more!
Quzzitch: What is the name of the Fat Lady's close friend?
Next week: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 8: Flight of The Fat Lady
This week's show is brought to you by Indeed (visit Indeed.com/MuggleCast to start hiring now) and HelloFresh (use code "muggle16" for 16 free meals at HelloFresh.com/Muggle16).
And don’t forget! There’s much more MuggleCast waiting for you on Patreon, including Bonus MuggleCast segments! This week, we discuss how the Harry Potter TV show could appeal more to adults! Become a patron of ours today at Patreon.com/MuggleCast! As always, we appreciate your support of the show!