The Office of Rabbi Sacks When Can We Lie? (Vayechi, Covenant & Conversation)
7 snips
Jan 7, 2025 The podcast explores the delicate balance of truth-telling within families, particularly through Jacob's death and the fears of his sons. It discusses the concept of white lies in Jewish law for the sake of peace, contrasting scriptural narratives with insights from Jewish sages. Philosophical reflections on human nature highlight a midrash about the creation of humanity, emphasizing tensions between truth and mercy. Finally, it tackles the complex relationship between truth and peace in Judaism, particularly within familial dynamics.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Joseph's Brothers' Lie
- Joseph's brothers feared his potential revenge after Jacob's death, despite earlier forgiveness.
- They lied about Jacob's dying wish, asking for forgiveness, to ensure peace.
God's Omission
- When Sarah laughed at the idea of having a child in old age, God omitted her comment about Abraham's age.
- The sages inferred this omission as promoting peace between the couple.
Principle of White Lies
- Both the Joseph and Sarah stories are needed to establish the principle of white lies for peace.
- God's similar act justifies the brothers' actions, allowing the principle's derivation.