One Nation, Indivisible with Andrew Seidel 035: Is Christian Nationalism... Christian? with Tim Whitaker
27 snips
Oct 21, 2025 Tim Whitaker, founder of the New Evangelicals, champions progressive Christianity and critiques evangelicalism. He delves into whether Christian nationalism truly represents Christianity, revealing it as a power-driven ideology. The conversation touches on Trump's odd views about heaven and the debate tactics that dominate social media. Tim emphasizes the importance of recognizing Christian nationalists as part of the faith, arguing it allows for necessary accountability. He advocates for a broader, more compassionate Christianity that focuses on justice and inclusion.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Viral Jubilee Debate Trap
- Tim debated Allie Beth Stuckey on a Jubilee panel and intentionally provoked her on slavery passages.
- The clip went viral and exposed evangelical rhetorical pivots on difficult biblical texts.
Christianity Is A Big House
- Christianity is a broad 'house' containing many conflicting traditions, including imperialist and oppressive streams.
- Christian nationalism sits inside that house even if it contradicts Christ-like teachings.
Christian Nationalism Uses Power, Not Jesus
- Christian nationalism is theologically Christian but anti-Christ in practice because it rarely quotes Jesus.
- It appeals to obscure Old Testament or Pauline passages to justify power and control.
