Do Nations Destroy Families? | Guest: Darryl Cooper | 1/26/24
Jan 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Darryl Cooper, podcast host and guest, discusses the tension between the bonds of patriotism and the bonds of kin. Topics include the impact of modern states on family structures, Stalin's destruction of cultural tradition, the loss of collective rights in society, the relationship between liberation of capital and destruction of lower time preference, the importance of supportive communities, and a discussion on politics, restoration, and an upcoming podcast episode.
The consolidation of power by states historically involved breaking down family connections among the nobility and reorienting loyalty to the king.
Incentivizing involvement in community institutions can foster a sense of belonging and representation in the larger state.
The decline of rooted family and community connections has led to a deficit of meaning and vulnerability to branded identities in modern society.
Deep dives
Tension Between Family Identity and National Identity
The podcast episode explores the tension between family identity and national identity, challenging the idea that strong families build strong nations. Historically, the consolidation of power by states involved breaking down family connections among the nobility and reorienting loyalty to the king. Traditional societies, however, nurtured family connections at the community level for self-governance. The modern state, particularly totalitarian regimes like the Soviet Union, directly attacked family authority, aiming to establish national loyalty. In the United States, family loyalty and national loyalty do not often come into conflict due to historical immigration patterns. However, the disconnection experienced by individuals in modern Western societies has led to a deficit of identity and a longing for meaningful connections.
Importance of Local Affinities and Institutions
The podcast discusses the importance of local affinities and institutions in building a stable society. In traditional societies, loyalty extended from family to community to nation, with each layer nurturing and supporting the ones closer to home. However, as the modern state emerged, it sought to establish national identity, often at the expense of local affinities. The breakdown of community connections and the loss of collective rights have led to a deficit of identity in modern societies. The podcast argues that incentivizing involvement in community institutions like labor unions, churches, and local organizations can foster a sense of belonging and representation in the larger state.
Consequences of Disconnection and Individualism
The episode explores the consequences of disconnection and individualism in modern society. With the decline of rooted family and community connections, many individuals feel a sense of homelessness and a lack of identity. While the freedom to create one's own identity is praised, it has also resulted in a deficit of meaning and vulnerability to branded identities. The episode highlights the importance of rooted and organic affiliations in fostering stability and a sense of purpose. It also questions whether fragmented societies can be put back together once these connections have been torn apart.
The Impact of Totalitarianism and Technology
The podcast delves into the impact of totalitarianism and technology on societies and their identities. Totalitarian regimes like the Soviet Union actively sought to break down family and community connections to establish state loyalty. In modern times, technology has accelerated disconnection and the erosion of social bonds. People's lives have increasingly shifted online, leaving them vulnerable to manipulation and the loss of social capital. The podcast raises concerns about the ability to resist propaganda and organize for collective action in a society where individuals are disconnected and heavily reliant on technology.
The Need for a Reconstituted Elite
The speaker discusses the decline of the Anglo power structure in the US, which had a sense of proprietary possession of the country. The power structure gradually disappeared in the 1960s and 70s, leading to a vacuum that allowed organized groups like the Neocons to take over American foreign policy. The speaker argues that reconstituting a legitimate elite with a profound understanding of power is necessary for maintaining the nation at a national level.
Regionalism and Rollback of Federal Power
The speaker proposes that the best way forward is a mix of regionalism, where people identify more with their states, regions, and local cultures, while also recognizing the benefits of remaining in a relationship with other regions of the country. This approach would require a severe rollback of federal power, which is unlikely to be achieved through legislation. The speaker emphasizes the importance of confronting the federal government and not relying on elected officials alone, but also acknowledges the need for caution to avoid a violent conflict or civil war.
The modern Right tends to see strong nations and strong families as synonymous, but the growth of the state requires the death of the extended clan. Darryl Cooper of the Martyr Made podcast joins me to discuss the natural tension between the bonds of patriotism and the bonds of kin.