Stuff You Should Know The Circleville Poison Pen Letters Mystery
Jan 11, 2022
For two decades, a small Ohio town was haunted by ominous poison pen letters. The saga includes accusations of infidelity, family tragedy, and a mysterious author's motives shrouded in jealousy. Lives were uprooted, with one man imprisoned amidst the chaos. Emotional fallout spiraled through the community, revealing deep secrets and tangled relationships. The discussion takes a psychological twist as it unravels the case's chilling legacy, leaving listeners questioning the true identity of the letter writer and their dark intentions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
The First Letter
- Mary Gillespie, a school bus driver in Circleville, Ohio, received an alarming letter accusing her of an affair with the school superintendent.
- Her husband, Ron, also received letters, prompting them to involve family members, including Paul Freshour, a former prison guard.
Escalation and Ron's Death
- Paul Freshour sent a letter to the suspected letter writer, David Longberry, another bus driver, warning him to stop.
- The letters ceased briefly, but resumed with escalating accusations involving the Gillespies' daughter and the superintendent.
Ron Gillespie's Death
- Ron Gillespie died in a single-vehicle car accident after receiving a call and leaving with a gun.
- His death was ruled a DUI, but suspicions arose due to a missing bullet and the location of the crash near his home.