
In Bed With The Right Episode 108 -- Live from San Francisco, It's Moral Panic Bingo Night!
Nov 25, 2025
Joined by cultural commentators Matt Bernstein and Sarah Marshall, the discussion dives into the world of moral panics. Matt details how AIDS panic perpetuated homophobia and shaped policy, while Sarah shares historical fears, like the windshield pitting myth from 1954. They explore themes like nostalgia, misinformation, and urban myths, such as the Halloween poisoning scare. The conversation wraps up with strategies for empathy and statistical literacy to counteract vulnerability to panics, making for a lively and insightful exchange.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
How Moral Panics Are Constructed
- Moral panics frame a marginal issue as a broad societal threat using stylized media narratives and respected authorities.
- Stanley Cohen's definition shows panics mix seriousness with daffiness and elite endorsement to gain traction.
Why Panics Simplify Complexity
- Moral panics simplify complex problems and often serve nostalgic or titillating purposes rather than accurate analysis.
- They depend on disproportionality and description creep to mobilize fear across audiences.
18th-Century Reading Scares
- Sarah Marshall recounts 18th-century reading panics that blamed novels for corrupting women and youth.
- She notes the Werther effect where a novel's suicide scene sparked real concerns about imitation suicides.







