Identity Crisis Nation: Resignations, Ratings, and the AI Martyr Machine

Two psychiatrists. One room. Zero buffer. And a political landscape having a full-blown identity crisis.

This week, David and Rob dig into the psychological mess behind Marjorie Taylor Greene’s sudden resignation announcement — a move that looks less like strategy and more like a total collapse of political identity. Once fused to MAGA, she’s now excommunicated, redefining herself in real time on CNN, and describing her role as that of a “battered spouse.” It’s pure identity fallout, and the guys unpack the cognitive and emotional wreckage. 

From there, the episode swerves into Trump’s approval-ratings-that-can’t-go-down — because when the polls tank, you can always just redefine who counts as “smart people.” It’s a masterclass in cognitive dissonance management, projection, and brand-preservation psychology. 

Then: the wildest development yet — an AI-generated Christian nationalist anthem titled We Are Charlie Kirk, created after the Turning Point founder’s assassination. The conversation hits the uncanny valley of AI-manufactured martyrdom, right-wing MeToo dynamics, trolling-as-religion, and how AI is now writing our political myths faster than we can fact-check them. 

The episode closes on Dick Cheney’s funeral — an unexpectedly poignant reflection on leadership, consistency, and the nostalgia for a political era where you could disagree with a politician and still respect them. Cheney held the line; the country feels like it’s losing it. “I miss old America,” Rob says — and for once, nobody jokes. 

In This Episode:

• MTG’s resignation and the psychological freefall of losing your political self
 • Why identity fusion makes political breakups feel like divorces
 • Trump’s approval polls and the art of redefining reality
 • AI-generated martyr worship and the rise of the algorithmic religion
 • Trauma bonding, out-group exile, and MAGA’s internal fragmentation
 • Dick Cheney’s legacy and the vanished value of authenticity in leadership

Prescriptions

• Politicians who resign: mandatory 6–12 month no-camera detox, no book deal, no podcast. Do one thing for your constituents — and you’re not allowed to tweet about it.
• State funerals: a required segment titled “Here’s What It Cost,” narrated by Morgan Freeman over a slide deck of uncomfortable truths. 

Two psychiatrists. One bottle of Old Forester. America in crisis.
 You’re not crazy — but the country might be.

"Got Thoughts? Outrage? A Diagnosis of Your Own? Send us a text"

Support the show

Shrink The Nation is where America lies on the couch — and we pour the bourbon.
Hosted by board-certified psychiatrists and mental health pros with backgrounds in military, media, and systems thinking, we break down the psychology behind politics, culture, and public dysfunction.
Smart. Funny. Clinically sharp. Slightly buzzed.

Subscribe, rate, and share if you’re part of the exhausted middle looking for sanity in the noise.

For feedback or hate-listening invitations, hit us at socials@shrinkthenation.com.

Follow us everywhere: @shrinkthenation on X, Instagram, Facebook and Bluesky

Shrink The Nation — On the Couch With America.