Matt Waldman, creator of the Rookie Scouting Portfolio and a seasoned Footballguys writer, dives into the 2025 rookie class. He evaluates standout prospects like Quinshon Judkins and Luther Burden while revealing his favorite sleeper picks. The discussion also covers the dynamics of fantasy drafts, emphasizing player fit and risk management. With insights on the evolution of skills in football and a spotlight on hidden gem Isaiah Nehrer, Waldman's analysis is a treasure trove for fantasy football enthusiasts.
Matt Waldman's extensive experience and dedication to scouting make his Rookie Scouting Portfolio a crucial resource for fantasy football enthusiasts and professionals.
Waldman emphasizes the significance of providing constructive criticism to players, respecting their hard work while helping them grow and improve their skills.
The depth of the 2023 running back class resembles a B+ to A- caliber, with evaluations focusing on both immediate impact and long-term potential.
Understanding draft capital and player personalities is essential for accurate evaluations, as they significantly influence a prospect's chances of success in the NFL.
Deep dives
Matt Waldman's Extensive Experience in Football Scouting
Matt Waldman has been involved in football analysis since 2006, particularly known for his detailed rookie scouting portfolio. This extensive experience allows him to provide unique insights into player evaluations, leveraging both film analysis and statistical data. As a senior staff writer for a football platform, he has built a reputation for combining humor and depth in his evaluations, making his work both informative and engaging. Waldman's dedication to scouting has made his rookie portfolio a valuable resource for fans and professionals alike.
The Unique Value of the Rookie Scouting Portfolio
Waldman's rookie scouting portfolio stands out for its extensive coverage of prospects, diving deeper into player evaluations than many other candidate reports. Unlike typical guides that focus on the top players, the portfolio includes a thorough analysis of all eligible players, encompassing a wide range of depth. This comprehensive approach ensures that readers not only receive information about potential stars but also lesser-known prospects who could make a significant impact. Waldman's commitment to detail positions his work as a crucial resource for both casual fans and dedicated fantasy football players.
Evaluating Constructive Criticism of Player Evaluation
Waldman discusses the challenge of providing negative feedback on player abilities while still respecting their dedication to the sport. He emphasizes the importance of offering constructive criticism rather than outright dismissals, acknowledging the hard work athletes invest in their careers. This approach allows scouts and analysts to maintain their credibility while encouraging players to develop their skills and improve. Waldman's philosophy reflects a supportive mindset that encourages growth and understanding in the competitive world of football.
Insights on the 2023 Running Back Class
The podcast discusses the depth and talent within the 2023 running back class, drawing comparisons to previous standout classes. Waldman suggests that while there are several quality players, the overall finish might resemble a B+ to A- caliber group depending on their performance in the NFL. He highlights that the evaluations of these running backs should take into account their potential long-term impact in terms of yardage and opportunities within their teams. This perspective emphasizes the blend of short-term projections with a long-term view on player development.
Understanding Draft Capital's Impact on Player Evaluation
Waldman explains the significance of draft capital concerning running back evaluations, noting that later selections often require multiple injuries to rise to prominence. He emphasizes the importance of analyzing the player's position on the depth chart to evaluate their chances of playing time. This understanding helps fantasy players adjust their expectations based on the team's current roster dynamics. Ultimately, being well-informed about draft capital allows scouts and analysts to form more accurate projections about a player's potential success in the NFL.
Waldman's Perspective on Player Personality and Success
The discussion also touches on the relevance of player personalities and their impact on success in the NFL, particularly regarding perceived off-field issues. Waldman suggests that if a player's behavior concerns teams, it could lower their draft stock and raise questions about their ability to contribute on the field. This reflects the realization that a player's mentality and attitude towards development play a significant role in their long-term potential. Waldman points out that understanding these subtleties can provide an edge in evaluating players and predicting their future success.
Highlighting Up-and-Coming Prospects
A notable name mentioned is Isaiah Nehrer, a receiver who has experience in multiple positions and possesses intriguing physical attributes. Despite injuries impacting his career trajectory, Nehrer's potential has not gone unnoticed, suggesting that he could be a hidden gem for teams looking for late-round value. Waldman's evaluation emphasizes the importance of identifying players who might have been overlooked due to circumstances beyond their control, such as injuries. This outlook encourages fans and analysts to remain vigilant about less prominent players who may surprise in the NFL.
The Constant Evolution of Football Analytics
Waldman expresses that football analytics continue to evolve, revealing new insights about player performance and recruiting strategies. The integration of advanced metrics and traditional scouting methods enables analysts to deliver more comprehensive evaluations of prospects. He notes that understanding how trends shift each season helps shape future analyses and predictions. This ongoing evolution in the field makes it essential for analysts to adapt and refine their approaches to maintain relevance and accuracy.
Matt Waldman is the creator of the Rookie Scouting Portfolio, and he's been a Footballguys senior staff writer for over 15 years. He joins Late-Round Perspectives -- for a second time -- to dig deep into this 2025 rookie class. You'll hear takes on Quinshon Judkins, Omarion Hampton, Luther Burden, Waldman's favorite sleepers, and so much more.
Order the Late-Round Prospect Guide on LateRound.com, and make sure to sign up for the free newsletter.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
