The Minefield

What’s the point of blame? When is it right to forgive?

22 snips
Sep 27, 2023
Miranda Fricker, Julius Silver Professor of Philosophy at NYU, explores the nuanced landscapes of blame and forgiveness. She discusses how cultural events like Yom Kippur shape our moral perspectives and the collective nature of repentance. Delving into various religious practices, she highlights the need for humility and recognition of faults. The conversation also touches on the challenges of communication surrounding forgiveness, especially in the context of historical injustices and collective guilt, advocating for accountability and compassion.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Yom Kippur: Vertical Confession

  • Yom Kippur confessions are directed vertically to God, lacking specific details of wrongdoing.
  • This vertical focus allows for self-reflection and acceptance of general human brokenness, a key aspect of atonement.
INSIGHT

Confession and Atonement Across Religions

  • Waleed Aly questions the difference between Yom Kippur and Christian atonement regarding confession.
  • He contrasts general confessions with the specific confessions in Catholicism, highlighting the role of crucifixion in Christian forgiveness.
INSIGHT

Specificity in Confessions

  • General confessions, like in Yom Kippur or some Christian practices, can be seen as evading responsibility.
  • Naming specific wrongs and confessing directly to the harmed person is crucial for true forgiveness, some argue.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app