Catholic Answers Live #12468 Did the Miracle of the Sun Actually Happen? - Tim Staples
Nov 21, 2025
Tim Staples, a senior apologist known for his expertise in Catholic doctrine, dives into the authenticity of the Miracle of the Sun, discussing eyewitness accounts and conversions sparked by the event. He also explores the relationship between God's will and personal manifestation, critiques prosperity theology, and clarifies the Mass as a propitiatory sacrifice. Additionally, Tim examines the significance of Ananias laying hands on St. Paul and addresses interpretations of Josephus regarding Jesus' brother, emphasizing the cultural meanings of 'adelphos'.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Church Approval Versus Required Belief
- The Church doesn't require belief in private revelations even when it approves them as worthy of pious belief.
- Tim Staples argues approval makes belief reasonable, though not obligatory, citing Fatima's public signs and witnesses.
Eyewitnesses, Photos, And Dry Ground At Fatima
- Tim Staples recounts tens of thousands, including skeptics and government agents, witnessing the October 13, 1917 Fatima phenomenon.
- He notes photos, conversions, and dried ground after heavy rain as striking corroborating details.
Family Conversion From Newspaper Accounts
- Tim shares a family story of his friend's grandmother converting after seeing Fatima photos in a U.S. newspaper.
- He uses this to illustrate how public reports led many nonbelievers to embrace Catholicism.
