The Free Will Show Episode 90: Sin and Free Will with Leigh Vicens
7 snips
Dec 23, 2024 Leigh Vicens, Associate Professor of Philosophy at Augustana University, delves into the intricate relationship between sin and free will within Christian thought. She explores theological determinism and compatibilism, unpacking their implications for human agency and moral responsibility. The discussion also critiques libertarian views, highlighting challenges like trans world depravity. Moreover, the conversation touches on universalism, addressing moral questions and inviting deeper reflection on the essence of divine justice and love.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
The Puzzle of Sin and Free Will
- Sin is puzzling because Christianity views it as both unavoidable and something we're responsible for.
- This creates tension between our lack of freedom regarding sin and our liability for it.
Compatibilism and Sin
- Compatibilists believe we're determined to sin yet free in sinning.
- This resolves the puzzle by accepting sin's unavoidability while maintaining responsibility.
Libertarianism and Sin
- Libertarians struggle with sin's unavoidability.
- They might argue sin is highly likely but not inevitable, or use middle knowledge to explain God's foreknowledge of universal sin.