Unlock the secrets of heist films as the hosts dissect their unique structure of desire versus object. Delve into the evolution of the genre and its interplay with crime and law enforcement. Explore psychological dynamics, from the allure of wealth to moral complexities in classics like 'Rififi' and 'Heat.' Discover how non-linear narratives enrich storytelling and challenge audiences. Lastly, examine the shifting portrayals of masculinity and femininity in iconic films and the societal issues woven into their plots.
Heist films are distinct from film noir, focusing on crime planning and execution, showcasing their popularity through structured narratives.
The central theme of desire versus its object highlights the characters' struggles, demonstrating how their goals often lead to disaster.
Collective labor in heist films fosters camaraderie among characters, differentiating them from noir's isolation, while exposing moral complexities in their actions.
Deep dives
The Heist Film as a Distinct Genre
The heist film is established as a distinct genre, emerged as a fork in the road from film noir. This distinction is attributed to the genre’s clear defining elements, such as the focus on planning, execution, and consequences of a crime. Unlike other genres that may blend or borrow elements without strict adherence, heist films consistently present narratives centered around the criminal act and the intricate details involved in the planning and execution. By tracing the genre's roots back to early examples like 'Asphalt Jungle,' it is emphasized that the heist film maintains a popularity that continues to thrive in contemporary cinema.
Antagonism Between Desire and Object
A central theme in heist films is the exploration of the antagonism between a character's desire and their object of desire. This dynamic often illustrates a disconnect where acquiring the desired object leads to eventual disaster, highlighting the futility of desire. Heist films like 'Ocean's Eleven' and 'Heat' embody this tension, showcasing how satisfaction of desire often eludes characters despite their best efforts. This theme provides depth to the plot, with treasures representing not only tangible objects but also the characters' motivations and the moral intricacies surrounding their choices.
Collective Labor in Successful Heists
The notion of collective labor plays a significant role in the structure of heist films, contrasting them with the isolative nature of film noir. In heist films, characters must collaborate effectively to execute their plans, creating a sense of camaraderie amidst criminality. During heists, the interplay of each character's skill is showcased, often leading to a successful theft — at least initially. This cooperative collective labor not only drives the narrative forward but also engages the audience by making them root for the criminals against the law.
Consequences and Moral Codes
A defining aspect of heist films is the moral code among the criminals, with adherence or violation of this code often leading to the downfall of the characters. These films examine the tension between loyalty, betrayal, and self-interest, indicating that maintaining the code among thieves is of utmost importance. In films like 'Rafifi' and 'Heat,' characters' internal codes dictate relationships and decisions, ultimately determining their fates. This exploration of moral complexities adds depth to the genre, inviting viewers to ponder the ethical dilemmas presented within.
The Evolution of Heist Narratives
Over time, heist films have adapted and evolved, creating new narratives that challenge traditional formulas. Contemporary examples like 'Inside Man' and the 'Ocean's' series reimagine classic elements, often blending humor and clever twists while maintaining the essence of the heist construct. Films such as 'Inside Man' cleverly subvert expectations by presenting a heist that transcends conventional boundaries, raising questions about justice and symbolically significant theft. The genre's capacity for innovation, while staying true to its foundational principles, ensures that heist films continue to captivate audiences.
Ryan and Todd develop their theory of the heist film as a genre, which they see as structured through the opposition between desire and its object. They examine closely Rififi, The Killing, Heat, Ocean's 11, and Inside Man, as well as touching on many other key films of the genre.
Hugh Manon's film noir podcast: https://open.spotify.com/show/0aQXewYjXrMtTjwpJ18rg6
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode