

Against Paul Kingsnorth
Nov 18, 2024
The hosts critically analyze Paul Kingsnorth's controversial Erasmus Lecture, debating his shift towards Eastern mysticism. They reflect on the complexities of Christian narratives, contrasting romanticized views of nature with urban theological insights. The conversation dives into Christ's relationship with power and the historical misinterpretations of Christian teachings. There's a deep exploration of grace, creativity, and the duality of creation, urging a more authentic expression of faith while reevaluating Christian values in today's world.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Initial Disagreement with Kingsnorth
- Brian was troubled by Paul Kingsnorth's Erasmus lecture, hosted by First Things magazine.
- Sebastian recalls a personal encounter where he posed a similar question to Kingsnorth at the Unheard Club.
Selective Gospel Interpretation
- Paul Kingsnorth selectively interprets Christ's sayings, focusing on those aligning with his predispositions.
- He presents these selected sayings as the essential, lost gospel.
Tolstoy's Literal Interpretation
- Leo Tolstoy, like Kingsnorth, interpreted Christ's teachings literally, leading to family conflict and social disruption.
- Tolstoy's attempt to live his ideals created a chaotic environment, not the Garden of Eden he envisioned.