Rev. Angela Denker, author of Red State Christians, explores the impact of white evangelical Christianity on Donald Trump's presidency. Topics covered include why white evangelicals supported Trump, complexities of evangelicalism, differences between black and white evangelical Christianity, and the link between Christian nationalism and Trump's support.
Evangelical support for Trump was driven by a focus on power and authority rather than lifestyle and character, which deviates from traditional evangelical values.
Christian nationalism and the alignment with Trump's messaging have become powerful forces within white evangelicalism, leading to the prioritization of power and self-promotion over true religious teachings.
Deep dives
Evangelicals' Support for Trump and the Shift in Demographics
Evangelicals played a significant role in Donald Trump's victory in the Iowa Republican caucus, with 53% of white evangelical Christians voting for Trump. This represents a significant increase from the 20% support he had from evangelicals in 2016. The support from evangelicals can be attributed to their focus on power and authority rather than lifestyle and character. White conservative Christians began rallying around social issues as a response to progress for minority groups. The intense support for Trump among evangelicals is reminiscent of religious devotion and authoritarian figures.
The Disconnect between Trump's Lifestyle and Evangelical Values
Trump's lifestyle and character do not align with traditional evangelical values. Many people, including Reverend Angela Danker, have observed that white American Christianity has strayed from the teachings of Jesus. The focus on power and control has overshadowed the values emphasized in the Bible. Despite this dissonance, Trump's appeal to insecurities and promises of security and superiority over others resonated with certain segments of white evangelicals.
Christian Nationalism and Radicalization
Christian nationalism and its alignment with Trump's messaging have become powerful forces within white evangelicalism. Large churches have become agents of radicalization, espousing revisionist history and promoting the culture wars. Many pastors have capitalized on this movement for personal gain, prioritizing power and self-promotion over true religious teachings. The challenge lies in resisting the intensifying influence and rhetoric of Christian nationalism and supporting leaders who uphold justice, truth, and inclusivity.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get benefits like zero ads on any Slate podcast, bonus episodes of shows like Slow Burn and Dear Prudence—and you’ll be supporting the work we do here on What Next. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to help support our work.