The Private School Leader Podcast

Episode 159: The Emotional Price Tag Of Suspending Or Expelling A Student

Nov 1, 2025
Navigating the emotional landscape of suspending or expelling a student is fraught with challenges. Guilt, grief, and compassion fatigue weigh heavily on school leaders. Discover strategies to reduce this emotional burden, including breathing techniques and seeking peer support. The conversation emphasizes the importance of separating emotions from the decision-making process and the necessity of debriefing after tough calls. Grieving the loss of a student community member is highlighted as a vital part of healing.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

The Personal Pain Of Discipline

  • Mark Minkus recalls the dread of calling parents before suspensions or expulsions and the emotional turmoil that followed each time.
  • He expelled children of a board member, a teacher, and a big donor, and says it was awful every single time.
INSIGHT

Five Emotional Costs Of Discipline

  • Minkus identifies five emotional costs of suspending or expelling students: guilt, grief, fear, compassion fatigue, and isolation.
  • He argues these emotions can accelerate burnout if unaddressed.
INSIGHT

How Emotion Alters Leadership

  • Past painful discipline decisions can change how leaders act, causing avoidance, inconsistency, overcompensation, and burnout.
  • Leading from fear instead of conviction undermines credibility and staff morale.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app