
The Theology Pugcast Protestantism and Modernity
30 snips
Oct 20, 2025 The hosts dive into the provocative claim that the Protestant Reformation sparked modernity and disenchantment, using Charles Taylor's A Secular Age as a basis. They explore how theological shifts and nominalism influenced the sacred worldview, and how differing Protestant traditions shaped desacralization. The discussion also includes the impact of memory practices on communal engagement, the complex role of witch trials, and the Enlightenment's diverse influences. Ultimately, they assert that blaming Protestants solely for modernity oversimplifies a rich historical interplay.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Reformation's Role In Disenchanting The World
- The Reformation contributed to a loss of sacramental emphasis, leveling of hierarchy, and devaluation of sacred objects, producing a sense of disenchantment.
- Those shifts helped create intellectual space for treating nature more mechanically, which later aided scientific inquiry.
Renaissance Was Full Of Magic, Not Just Science
- Renaissance thought was deeply entangled with magic and Hermeticism, not a pure dawn of science.
- The 17th century reaction replaced magic with rising rationalism and new methods of explanation.
Nominalism And Franciscan Voluntarism's Legacy
- Late medieval Franciscan reforms and nominalism shaped voluntarist theology that emphasized moral effort and congruent grace.
- That voluntarism influenced later Protestant thinkers like Luther and contributed to intellectual shifts away from Thomistic sacramentalism.





