Gita Gopinath, IMF's first deputy managing director, discusses trade fragmentation and fears of a new Cold War. They also explore global growth, inflation, central bank approaches, attacks on Red Sea shipping lanes, addressing Argentina's economic problems, India's economic success, and the potential impact of AI on the global economy.
The rise of trade fragmentation along geopolitical lines can potentially lead to a new Cold War, driven by factors such as the pandemic, security concerns, and US-China competition.
Countries should diversify their supply chains and avoid excessive reliance on a single country while cautiously considering the potential economic and political risks of protectionist trade policies.
Deep dives
Trade Fragmentation and the Risk of a New Cold War
In an essay for Foreign Policy, Gita Gopinath, Deputy Managing Director of the IMF, highlights the rise of trade fragmentation along geopolitical lines. She notes that in 2023, there were 3,000 new trade restrictions imposed, three times the number in 2019, and this trend can lead to a new Cold War. However, Gopinath emphasizes that this is not the same as deglobalization, as global trade as a share of GDP remains high. Factors contributing to fragmentation include the pandemic, security concerns, US-China competition, and conflicts like Russia's war in Ukraine. Gopinath acknowledges the potential for a slippery slope towards protectionism and expresses limited optimism that countries may contain the extent of decoupling.
The Impact of Trade Restrictions and Fragmentation
Gopinath explains that trade restrictions are affecting countries' trade strategies and supply chains, leading to a shift towards trading more with partners within their own blocs. She highlights the decrease in US foreign direct investment in China and the redirection towards countries like India, Mexico, and the UAE. The fragmentation of trade is an increasing reality, driven by various factors such as national security concerns, the pandemic, and geopolitical tensions. Gopinath urges countries to diversify their supply chains and avoid excessive reliance on a single country, while cautiously considering the potential economic and political risks of protectionist trade policies.
The Cost and Complexity of Cold War II
Gopinath addresses the risks associated with a new Cold War. Compared to the original Cold War, current economies are far more integrated, with global trade accounting for a much larger share of GDP. Gopinath warns that a new Cold War would be costly for all economies, given the level of interconnectivity. She expresses limited optimism that countries may try to contain decoupling, considering the economic consequences and complexity of such a scenario. Rational minds, Gopinath suggests, may pause and weigh the potential high costs of entering Cold War II against the benefits of maintaining global economic stability.
Protectionism and US Policy
Gopinath acknowledges that the US-China trade tensions under the previous administration have contributed to rising trade restrictions globally. She notes that some of these restrictions were responses to perceived violations of trade rules, highlighting the need for a more level playing field in global trade. However, Gopinath cautions against excessive protectionism, as it can lead to a retaliatory cycle with countermeasures undermining the limited benefits of protectionist policies. She highlights the importance of recognizing both political and economic factors in trade decisions while seeking a balance between protecting national interests and maintaining stable trade relations.
Economics is sometimes called the “dismal science.” But the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has a surprisingly positive outlook for the U.S. economy—even if public sentiment hasn’t yet caught up. Host Ravi Agrawal discusses the state of the global economy with Gita Gopinath, the IMF’s first deputy managing director. The two begin with Gopinath’s latest essay in Foreign Policy about trade fragmentation and fears of a new Cold War.