Effectively Wild Episode 2076: Plunk Me Twice, Shame on You
Oct 25, 2023
auto_awesome
Discussion on ALCS and NLCS games, including Adolis García's heroics and the Rangers defeating the Astros. Critique of MLB's handling of Bryan Abreu's suspension and Craig Kimbrel's career. Reactions to the Giants hiring Bob Melvin as their manager.
A need for clarity in discipline and a strategic approach in responding to losses highlighted by MLB's inconsistent suspension of Giancarlo Abreu and the Astros' whining
Positive and gracious demeanor of Chris Young and Evan Carter added to the joy and excitement of the playoffs
Commendable management by Bruce Bochy, minimizing mistakes and allowing his team to execute effectively
Absence of a competitive home team in the Rangers vs Astros series reduced the energy and intensity of the crowd
Deep dives
Astros' Whining and Inconsistencies in Discipline
The Astros' response to their loss, characterized by whining, paranoia, and conspiracy theories, was not the most gracious. The league's decision to suspend Giancarlo Abreu for intentionally throwing at a batter, only to have the suspension served in the next regular season, was seen as inconsistent and ineffective in deterring future bad behavior.
Chris Young and Evan Carter's Enthusiasm
Chris Young's positive and gracious demeanor in the post-game interviews was refreshing, while Evan Carter's youthful exuberance added to the team's joy and excitement. Both players highlighted the fun they were having in the playoffs.
Bruce Bochy's Effective Management
Bruce Bochy's management throughout the series was commendable, as he made minimal mistakes and allowed his team to execute their game plan effectively.
Rangers vs Astros Rivalry
The Rangers vs Astros rivalry was somewhat muted in the series, as the home team consistently lost. The absence of a competitive home team reduced the energy and intensity of the crowd, making the atmosphere less exciting.
The Need for Clarity in Discipline and Response
The league's decision and the Astros' response highlight the need for clarity in discipline and a more strategic approach in responding to losses. Whining and conspiracy theories undermine the team's image and do not generate sympathy from others. Fans should focus on their own team's progress and investment instead of criticizing others.
Diamondbacks and Phillies meet in World Series
The Diamondbacks and Phillies are set to face off in the World Series. Both teams have had memorable moments throughout the postseason, with players like Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber showcasing their power hitting abilities. The Diamondbacks have been more aggressive on the base paths, showing a new dimension to their game. On the pitching side, both teams have faced some challenges, including the use of Ryan Kirkering in high-pressure situations. The series promises to be exciting, with the outcome uncertain. Regardless of who wins, there will be some standout performances and emotions at the end.
Bob Melvin departs Oakland A's
Bob Melvin, the highly respected manager of the Oakland A's, is reportedly leaving the team to manage the San Francisco Giants. This move suggests a significant rift between Melvin and the A's front office. Melvin's successful tenure with the A's includes multiple postseason appearances and three Manager of the Year awards. However, his departure to a division rival indicates strained relations. It remains to be seen how this managerial change will impact the A's in the long run and what the future holds for Melvin with the Giants.
Ben Lindbergh and Meg Rowley discuss assorted ALCS and NLCS action and playoff takeaways and trends, with an emphasis on Adolis García’s heroics, the Rangers vanquishing the Astros, MLB’s handling of Bryan Abreu’s suspension, and Craig Kimbrel’s career (plus reactions to the Giants hiring Bob Melvin as their manager). Audio intro: The Shirey Brothers, “Effectively Wild […]
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
