Politicians need to embrace philosophical thinking to build more effective and honest political frameworks by paying attention, asking critical questions, and avoiding cluster thinking.
Integration of epistemic virtues, such as accuracy and sincerity, can enhance the quality of political discourse and decision-making by fostering a commitment to truth and critical thinking.
Deep dives
The Importance of Philosophical Thinking in Politics
In this podcast episode, the conversation centers around the role of philosophical thinking in politics. The guest speaker, Julian Bajini, discusses the need for politicians to embrace a more philosophical perspective when dealing with real-world issues and public discourse. He argues that good thinking in politics requires not only technical skills like logical reasoning but also virtues like accuracy and sincerity. Bajini emphasizes the importance of slowing down, paying attention, and asking critical questions to avoid jumping to conclusions. While it's acknowledged that the fast-paced nature of frontline politics presents challenges, Bajini and the host, Jesse Norman, agree that there are moments, particularly during policy formulation, where philosophical thinking can be integrated to build more effective and honest political frameworks.
Addressing Cluster Thinking and Overcoming Partisan Bias
Bajini highlights the issue of cluster thinking in politics, where certain views are assumed to form a set, leading to a polarized and oversimplified understanding of complex issues. He gives examples like the association of climate change with the left and the assumption that discussing migration problems automatically makes one right-wing. Bajini argues for the importance of breaking free from cluster thinking and embracing a more nuanced and comprehensive approach to political issues. He advocates for politicians who can speak to both emotions and reason, combining the qualities of ethos, pathos, and logos in their communication. Bajini and Norman discuss the need for politicians to be able to slow down, ask critical questions, and engage in honest discussions that address trade-offs and complexities. They express optimism about the possibility of overcoming partisan bias and fostering a more philosophical approach in politics.
Applying Epistemic Virtues to Political Decision-Making
The concept of epistemic virtues, referred to as the 'p-factor' by Bajini, is discussed in the podcast. Epistemic virtues encompass sincerity, accuracy, and other virtues of thought that contribute to good thinking. Bajini emphasizes the need for politicians to slow down, pay attention, be accurate with facts, and represent opposing arguments fairly and sincerely. He points out that intelligent and articulate individuals can fall into the trap of favoring arguments that align with their preconceived beliefs. Bajini urges politicians to approach decision-making with a commitment to accuracy, sincerity, and a genuine pursuit of truth. While acknowledging the challenges of operating in a fast-paced political environment, he argues that the integration of epistemic virtues can enhance the quality of political discourse and decision-making.
The Role of Philosophy in Policy Formulation and Governance
The podcast touches upon the role of philosophy in policy formulation and governance. Bajini suggests that political parties, particularly during periods of opposition, should engage in philosophical thinking when shaping their policies. He acknowledges that the front line of politics may require quick decision-making, but emphasizes the importance of integrating philosophical questioning and critical thinking even in time-sensitive situations. Bajini and Norman discuss the distinction between parliamentary activity and governing, highlighting the need for normative orientation towards truth and accuracy in politics. They explore the challenges of balancing discreet discussions and collective decision-making processes. Overall, the conversation stresses the value of philosophy in politics and encourages politicians to adopt philosophical thinking at appropriate moments to facilitate effective policy formation and governance.
Philosopher Julian Baggini shares the insights of his new book How to Think Like a Philosopher: Essential Principles for Clearer Thinking. In conversation with government minister Jesse Norman, who was himself once an academic philosopher, Baggini set out the techniques, methods and principles that guide philosophy, and show how they can be applied to our own lives – and our politics. Using precepts such as: pay attention, question everything, follow the facts, and think for yourself but not by yourself, Baggini shows how clearer thinking can help us meet the challenges of our troubled times.
We’d love to hear your feedback and what you think we should talk about next, who we should have on and what our future debates should be.
Send us an email or voice note with your thoughts to podcasts@intelligencesquared.com or Tweet us @intelligence2.
And if you’d like to support our mission to foster honest debate and compelling conversations, as well as ad-free podcasts, exclusive bonus content, early access and much more, become a supporter of Intelligence Squared today.
Just visit intelligencesquared.com/membership to find out more.
