#53 Answering Protestant Objections to Purgatory - Joe Heschmeyer
Nov 30, 2023
auto_awesome
Joe Heschmeyer, an apologist, addresses Protestant objections to Purgatory. The podcast explores biblical evidence supporting Purgatory, including Isaiah's vision and the concept of being saved as through fire. They also discuss different degrees of glory in heaven and the relevance of punishment and discipline for believers according to scripture. Misunderstandings in biblical interpretation are explored, and the significance of 2nd Maccabees in understanding Purgatory is discussed.
The good thief's statement on the cross does not disprove the existence of purgatory, as there are different interpretations that suggest immediate purification and entry into heaven that very day.
Some Protestants deny the idea of temporal consequences for sin, but the New Testament highlights the presence of consequences, emphasizing the moral duty of believers to care for the spiritual suffering, including those in purgatory.
A plain language reading of biblical texts may lead to misinterpretation, as many passages require deeper interpretation and context to fully understand their meaning.
Deep dives
The concept of purgatory is biblically reasonable
The podcast episode explores the idea that purgatory is a reasonable concept based on biblical teachings. It emphasizes the belief that nothing impure can enter heaven, and since most people leave earth with sin, some form of purification or cleansing is necessary before entering heaven.
Different interpretations of the good thief on the cross
The good thief's statement on the cross, 'Today you will be with me in paradise,' is discussed. The podcast acknowledges different interpretations, including the possibility that the good thief experienced immediate purification and entered heaven that very day. However, it remains unclear and is not necessarily an argument against the existence of purgatory.
Protestants denying consequences for sin
The podcast highlights how some Protestants deny the idea of any temporal consequences for sin. However, it emphasizes that consequences for sin are evident in the New Testament, and that believers have a moral duty to care for those spiritually suffering, including the Holy Souls in purgatory.
Questioning the plain language reading of biblical texts
The podcast challenges the notion of relying solely on a plain language reading of biblical texts. It suggests that many passages require deeper interpretation and context to fully understand their meaning, and that taking a surface-level reading can lead to misinterpretation.
The need for ongoing purification and prayers for the dead
The podcast promotes the idea that ongoing purification is necessary, and that prayers for the dead, including those in purgatory, are important. It encourages Protestants to acknowledge the need for purification and Catholics to focus on the finished work of Jesus while caring for those in need of spiritual purification.