Episode 522: Learn the ZIZEK EQUATION that Explains FAKE NEWS
Jan 24, 2024
auto_awesome
Author David Shields discusses his upcoming book on fake news and explores the challenges of distinguishing truth from fiction in a world influenced by Western Thought. The podcast analyzes the Black Mirror episode 'Joan is Awful' to illustrate key ideas from Shields' book, including the concept of reality in art and literature. It also explores topics such as self-authorship, measuring value from a Marxist perspective, and the portrayal of characters in TV shows.
'Joan is Awful' presents public humiliation as a path to redemption and normality for Joan.
David Shields' book How We Got Here explores the erosion of truth and the crisis of nonfiction in the current political climate, affecting our ability to discern reality and navigate our own lives.
Deep dives
Exploring the Trope of 'Your Whole Life is Fake'
In the podcast, the first episode of Black Mirror's sixth season, titled 'Joan is Awful,' is analyzed. The episode is a variation of the trope where someone discovers their entire life is fake. It draws inspiration from previous works like 'A World of Difference,' 'Special Service,' 'The Truman Show,' and 'The Secret Cinema.' 'Joan is Awful' tells the story of an office worker named Joan, whose life is being turned into an entertainment show without her knowledge. Her every move is recorded by her phone, and a supercomputer generates a Netflix original series with deep fakes of celebrities playing all the roles. While in 'The Secret Cinema,' the protagonist's humiliation leads to her destruction, 'Joan is Awful' presents public humiliation as a path to redemption and normality for Joan.
Challenging the Notions of Truth and Narrative
The Black Mirror episode 'Joan is Awful' reflects on the societal shift from valuing truth to narratives. It compares the episode to 'The Truman Show,' where a real person is trapped in a simulated world. In contrast, 'Joan is Awful' tells the story of a fake person whose real life is turned into a television show against her will. In this world, smartphones secretly record every fake person, while a quantum computer combines AI and deep fakes to create a televisual story centered around Joan. The episode blurs the lines between reality, the audience, and the television show. It highlights the disappearance of the real world and the loss of truth, leaving individuals with managed private lives directed by invisible networks of control.
The Crisis of Truth and Perception
David Shields' book How We Got Here, discussed in the podcast, explores the erosion of truth and the crisis of nonfiction. It delves into the clash between reality and narrative, the rise of fake news, and the difficulty in distinguishing fact from fiction. The book argues that reality is not merely a matter of bare facts but is influenced by subjective interpretations and societal constructs. In the current political climate, the concept of truth is questioned, and fact-checkers themselves can be biased. The podcast emphasizes how this crisis of truth, explored in 'Joan is Awful,' extends to our societal and political discourse, affecting our ability to discern reality and navigate our own lives.
David Shield's is the author of the upcoming book "How We Got Here" along with dozens of other bestselling books such as "Reality Hunger" and "The Thing About Life is One Day You'll Be Dead." In this episode of Diet Soap Douglas Lain uses the Black Mirror Episode "Joan is Awful" as an example that helps to explain the ideas in David Shield's' book.