The NPR Politics Podcast Is Impeachment About More Than Removal? Depends Who You Ask
Feb 4, 2021
The podcast dives into the constitutional debates surrounding the impeachment trial of a former president. It contrasts perspectives on whether a Senate trial remains valid after a president leaves office. Historical precedents are examined, shedding light on past impeachments and their relevance today. The discussion also touches on the implications of political speech and accountability, particularly regarding accusations of incitement. Overall, it presents a nuanced view of the intertwining of law, history, and politics in this unprecedented situation.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Impeachment Post-Office
- The Founding Fathers intended to allow impeachment convictions after an official leaves office.
- This interpretation is supported by the clause about barring convicted officials from holding future federal office.
Belknap Precedent
- William Belknap, a corrupt Secretary of War under President Grant, resigned to avoid impeachment.
- Despite his resignation, the House impeached him, and the Senate tried him, setting a precedent.
Free Speech Defense
- Trump's defense argues that his speech before the Capitol riot is protected by the First Amendment.
- They claim it was about election security in general, not a call to action at the Capitol.