The Channel McGilchrist Podcast Understanding The Matter with Things Dialogues Episode 13: Chapter 13 - Institutional science & truth
18 snips
Oct 7, 2024 Dive into the intriguing interplay between institutional science and truth, exploring how human factors influence scientific assertions. The discussion critiques the reliance on specialized knowledge and the impact of corporate interests in research. Replication's critical role in validating findings is examined, alongside the challenges of misconduct and conformity that threaten innovation. Delving into the etymology of key terms reveals deeper meanings tied to trust and genuine experience, encouraging a more inclusive and meaningful engagement with science.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Neuroimaging's Seductive Images
- Neuroimaging's colorful brain images are seductive but oversimplified, potentially misrepresenting brain activity.
- Factors like effort, individual differences (sex, age, race), and the nature of the task significantly affect neuroimaging results.
The Importance of Replication
- Replicability is crucial for validating scientific results, ensuring they're not lab-specific anomalies.
- Positive results are favored over negative or non-replicable results, creating publication bias.
Reproducibility vs. Replicability
- Reproducibility, distinct from replicability, becomes challenging with expensive, specialized equipment.
- Many labs cannot afford or access the technology required to reproduce certain experiments, limiting verification.