Author of Suicide of the West, Jonah, discusses Jews, American journalism decline, and optimism for the future on a lively podcast filled with humor and insights
Journalists lack the daring spirit of the past, leading to a more subdued approach in modern journalism.
Characters in 'Civil War' showcase varied ambitions in journalism, challenging traditional heroic narratives.
The film 'Civil War' prompts reflection on personal ambitions driving journalism, offering a critical view on evolving portrayals in media.
Deep dives
Journalistic Swagger and the Loss of Heroic Narratives
Jack Shafer's piece in Politico discusses the decline of journalistic swagger, highlighting that journalists today lack the daring and crusading spirit of the past. This points to a shift in journalism toward a more subdued and less adventurous approach. The notion of journalists as swashbuckling figures challenging authority and seeking truth has waned, signaling a broader change in the media landscape.
Exploring the Futility of War and Journalistic Intentions
In the film 'Civil War,' the portrayal of war and journalism challenges traditional heroic narratives and explores the personal motivations behind journalistic pursuits. Characters represent a mix of ambitions, from seeking fame to adrenaline seeking, showcasing a nuanced view of the reasons behind journalism. The death of a character underscores the futility and horror of war when devoid of noble purpose or meaning.
Reflection on Changing Times in Journalism
The film 'Civil War' prompts reflection on the shifting dynamics within journalism, portraying characters driven by personal ambitions rather than lofty ideals. This introspective take on war and journalistic intentions highlights a departure from traditional heroic portrayals in media. It offers a critical view on the complexities and motivations that drive individuals in the field of journalism.
Challenging Traditional Narratives of Heroism in Media
In 'Civil War,' the narrative challenges conventional heroic depictions in journalism by portraying characters driven by personal desires rather than noble causes. This departure from traditional portrayals prompts viewers to reassess the motivations and complexities behind journalistic endeavors. The film provides a thought-provoking perspective on the evolving nature of heroism and ambition in media portrayals.
Evolution of Journalism Culture
The podcast delves into the historical shift in journalism culture, highlighting the evolution from a time of sociopathic hijinks and sensational storytelling to a more sanitized and professional approach. It discusses the roots of this change, tracing it back to the Hemingway era and the romanticized image of daring foreign correspondents. The narrative contrasts the wild and often fabricated anecdotes shared by past journalists with the current trend towards a more buttoned-up and fact-focused style.
Media Landscape Transformation
The episode explores the transformation in media dynamics over the years, pointing out shifts in values and priorities within the industry. It discusses how the allure of fame and quick success has influenced individuals within journalism, leading to a preference for television appearances over traditional reporting. The narrative touches upon the impact of sensationalism and audience demands on journalistic integrity, highlighting the challenges faced in maintaining consistency and honesty in a media landscape driven by performative narratives and entertainment value.
Jonah drops by Commentary’s New York headquarters and holds John Podhoretz hostage for an hour and a half to discuss the Jews, Suicide of the West, and the allure of fame and TV. Stay tuned for a history of Commentary’s geographical history (who asked?), the decline of American journalism (spoilers!), and optimism about the future (really?). Also, happy birthday to The Fair Jessica.