110. Luddism: 19th Century Direct Action against TechnoCapitalism -- Brian Merchant
Dec 6, 2023
auto_awesome
Brian Merchant, author of 'Blood in the Machine,' discusses the Luddites' true intentions, highlighting their critique of technology and its relevance today. He explores the impact of automation on historical systems and marginalized groups, dispels misconceptions about Luddites, and explores their resistance against factory and automation in the 19th century. The chapter also delves into the clash of ideologies in early capitalism and the shift towards a factory model of work.
The Luddites protested against the negative impact of automation on workers' wages and quality of work, resorting to machine breaking as a tactic of disruption.
The emergence of the job model, where workers sell their labor to a centralized authority, led to a loss of autonomy and dignity, sparking resistance against the oversight and control imposed by factory owners.
The state played a significant role in suppressing the Luddite movement, prioritizing the interests of the wealthy elites over workers' concerns, and cementing the path of industrialization.
The Luddite movement aimed to create a different system that respects workers' rights and autonomy, highlighting the importance of incorporating technological advancements while prioritizing fair and equitable conditions for workers.
The Luddite movement emphasizes the need to critically examine the organization of work, the role of the state, and potential inequalities arising from automation, advocating for fair wages, welfare support, and protection against exploitative practices.
Deep dives
The Luddites and their Fight Against Automation
The Luddites were skilled technicians who recognized the negative impact of the industrial revolution on their livelihood. They protested against the use of automating machinery that decreased wages and quality of work. Facing political resistance and a lack of unionization rights, they resorted to machine breaking as a tactic to disrupt the implementation of automation. The Luddites were disciplined and organized, sending warning letters to factory owners before carrying out their raids. The state responded with a massive occupation, using military force to crush the Luddite movement. This period exemplifies the tension between technological development and workers' rights, with the state prioritizing the interests of the wealthy elites over the concerns of the working class.
The Impact of Jobs and the Loss of Autonomy
The emergence of the job model, where workers sell their labor to a centralized authority, was a key factor in the push for automation. The Luddites sensed the loss of autonomy and dignity that came with the job system and resented the oversight and control imposed by factory owners. The idea of standing at someone's command and being watched over in a windowless room evoked revulsion among the workers. The reluctance of people to return to traditional office jobs during the pandemic reflects the ongoing aversion to this model of work, highlighting the need to reassess the organization of work in modern society.
The State's Role in Shaping Industrial Progress
The state played a significant role in the development of technology and its impact on society during the Luddite uprising. Rather than allowing the market to dictate technological advancement, the state intervened forcefully to protect the interests of the wealthy elites. Massive state resources were deployed to crush the Luddite movement, including troops and militia occupying industrial districts. This intervention cemented the path of industrialization, favoring the consolidation of power and the exploitation of labor. The state's choices to suppress workers' resistance rather than address their concerns perpetuated an exploitative system.
The Quest for an Alternative Arrangement
The Luddites' fight against automation should not be seen as an anti-technology stance, but rather as a struggle for a different system that respects workers' rights and autonomy. The Luddites were skilled technicians themselves and embraced technology when it was in line with their values and aspirations. Their protest was a response to the negative consequences of industrialization and the unequal distribution of power. The Luddite movement demonstrates the possibility of exploring alternative arrangements that incorporate technological advancements while prioritizing fair and equitable conditions for workers.
Lessons from the Luddite Movement
The Luddite movement serves as a reminder that technological progress must not come at the expense of workers' well-being and autonomy. It highlights the need to critically examine the organization of work, the role of the state, and the potential inequalities arising from automation. The Luddites' calls for fair wages, welfare support, and protection against exploitative practices are still relevant today. Their resistance serves as a testament to the importance of solidarity and the fight against power imbalances in the modern workplace.
I'm joined by Brian Merchant to discuss his new book, Blood in the Machine. Brian argues persuasively that the Luddites weren't anti-technology but were actually for a different social order and a different use of technology. More importantly, in Brian's book the factory owners look a lot like today's tech titans and the workers look a lot like, well, today's workers. So come back with us to the early 19th century to find out how it all went wrong!
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode