The Next Best Picture Podcast "Marty Supreme"
Dec 28, 2025
Dive into the whirlwind of 'Marty Supreme,' where Timothée Chalamet shines in a tale inspired by table tennis legend Marty Reisman. The electrifying New York Film Festival premiere left audiences buzzing over Josh Safdie's polished direction. The hosts explore Chalamet's potential career-best performance and the film's themes of ambition and identity. With memorable comedic moments and striking cinematography, they also debate its awards prospects and what winning truly costs. A compelling blend of hustle, humor, and heart awaits!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Safdie’s Mature, Bigger-Scale Voice
- Josh Safdie's solo film retains his signature energy but shows increased polish and sincerity compared to earlier work.
- The movie reframes American exceptionalism through a kinetic, character-driven sports tale set in 1950s New York.
Ambition Framed By Identity
- The film centers on Marty's relentless, often toxic drive and uses Jewish-American identity as both shield and motivation.
- This framing ties his hustle to post‑WWII immigrant survival and American individualism themes.
Crowd Reactions Shape Perception
- Katie and others shared audience reactions: some lines (Auschwitz jokes) made viewers uncomfortable while still fitting Marty's character.
- Multiple viewings with different crowds revealed how loud reactions can mask dialogue that later reads more clearly on rewatch.