Jed Lipinski, writer and host of the gripping podcast Gone South, takes listeners into the life of Buford Pusser, the legendary Tennessee sheriff. They discuss the shocking contradictions in Pusser's heroic image, exacerbated by the mysterious death of his wife, Pauline. Listeners learn about the blurred lines between truth and myth, particularly influenced by the film 'Walking Tall.' Lipinski also sheds light on the community issues stemming from Pusser's legacy, including the pressing needs of senior food insecurity.
Buford Pusser's iconic status as a heroic lawman has been complicated by new investigations into his wife Pauline's unresolved murder case.
The cultural impact of Pusser's life and the film 'Walking Tall' challenges audiences to reassess the myth versus the reality of his legacy.
Deep dives
The Life and Legacy of Buford Pusser
Buford Pusser was a legendary sheriff of McNary County, Tennessee, known for his larger-than-life persona and his crusade against local corruption. He rose to fame during the 1960s, often depicted as a hero standing up to the Dixie Mafia and other criminal organizations in the area. His story inspired numerous media portrayals, including books and films like "Walking Tall," which highlighted his valor and determination to clean up his town. However, the recent exhumation of his wife, Pauline Pusser, whose unresolved murder has long haunted his legacy, casts a shadow over the unwavering image of Pusser as a righteous lawman, suggesting that his narrative may be more complicated than previously believed.
The Unsolved Murder of Pauline Pusser
The ambush and murder of Pauline Pusser in 1967 remains one of Tennessee's most infamous cold cases, with the circumstances surrounding her death still shrouded in mystery. Pauline was shot during a violent attack while traveling with Buford, leaving unanswered questions about who orchestrated the ambush. An investigative breakthrough occurred when authorities discovered that no autopsy had ever been performed on her body, which many consider a significant oversight that might have provided critical evidence. The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation's reopening of the case could potentially lead to new insights, but it also raises disturbing questions about why such an examination was neglected at the time.
Questions Surrounding the Ambush Incident
Numerous inconsistencies in Buford Pusser's account of the night of the ambush have fueled speculation regarding the true nature of the attack. Investigators and individuals like Mike Elam have raised concerns about why Buford would take his wife on a disturbance call, as such situations are inherently risky. Additionally, there are doubts about the chosen route to the beer hall, which seemed unnecessarily convoluted compared to a more direct path, leaving room for questioning the planning of the ambush. The examination of the blood spatter and shell casing positions has suggested that Buford's version of events may not align with the physical evidence found at the scene.
The Cultural Impact of Buford Pusser's Story
Buford Pusser's life has influenced popular culture profoundly, transforming him from a local lawman into a mythic figure akin to American folk heroes. His story, particularly as depicted in the film "Walking Tall," resonated with audiences, leading to a narrative that romanticized his fight against crime and corruption. The enduring legacy has led to ongoing fascination and respect for Pusser's persona, even inspiring subsequent generations, including Dwayne Johnson, who described the film as formative in shaping his values. As the new investigation brings to light previously overlooked evidence and perspectives, it challenges the glorified narrative of Pusser, urging a reevaluation of the complexities intertwined with his celebrated legacy.
Here's an episode from a podcast that you may enjoy. Presenting Gone South.
This episode looks at the life and legacy of Buford Pusser, an iconic American law enforcement figure. The film "Walking Tall," starring Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson, is based on Pusser's life as a cop. But recent revelations are turning Pusser's legacy on its head.
Gone South, an Audacy original podcast, is available now on the free Audacy app and wherever you get your podcasts.