Kristie Flannery, "Piracy and the Making of the Spanish Pacific World" (U Pennsylvania Press, 2024)
Jul 28, 2024
auto_awesome
Dr. Kristie Flannery, an expert on Spanish colonial rule in the Philippines, discusses her groundbreaking work on piracy's role in shaping the Spanish Pacific World. She reveals how colonial officials and missionaries allied with Indigenous Filipinos and Chinese migrants to combat piracy. The conversation delves into the unexpected influence of Catholic priests in legitimizing imperial power. Flannery also explores the tumultuous Sino-Spanish relations, highlighting the fluctuating fates of Chinese immigrants amid piracy and colonial tensions.
Spanish colonial policies in the Philippines were shaped by collaboration with local populations against piracy, fostering unique alliances for mutual survival.
The fluctuating dynamics between Spanish authorities and the Chinese population highlight the complex interplay of welcome and violent expulsion influenced by piracy.
Deep dives
The Intersection of Colonial Powers and Piracy
The episode explores how piracy significantly influenced Spanish colonial policies in the Philippines, particularly concerning Moro piracy, which was identified as Muslim raids from Mindanao. Spanish sources homogenized these raiders into a single category, ignoring the diverse identities involved. Additionally, the raids had profound economic implications for local communities, as they disrupted agricultural production and tribute payments, fueling the crisis of legitimacy for the Spanish Empire. The colonial government's strategy to tackle piracy involved collaboration with indigenous populations, showcasing a unique alliance born out of shared interests against a common enemy.
The Role of Catholic Missions in Governance
The involvement of Catholic priests in the anti-piracy campaigns highlights their dual role as spiritual leaders and local administrators within the Spanish colonial framework. Priests were often the only Spanish representatives in remote communities, wielding significant social influence and facilitating critical negotiations between the colonial state and indigenous communities. Their efforts to create alliances against piracy were essential in maintaining imperial legitimacy beyond urban centers, as they worked closely with local populations. This relationship complicated the narrative of colonial oppression, revealing a dynamic of mutual dependency shaped by shared economic and religious objectives.
Shifting Sino-Spanish Relations and Violence
The complex relationship between the Spanish colonial officials and the Chinese population in the Philippines is likened to a pendulum, swinging between periods of welcome and violent expulsion. The episode details how the rise of Chinese piracy, during tumultuous changes in China, influenced the Spanish perception of their Chinese subjects, leading to mass killings of Chinese residents in the 17th and 18th centuries. The aftermath of British occupation in Manila exacerbated fears of Chinese complicity in piracy, prompting the colonial government to carry out systematic expulsions of Chinese men. This reflects broader themes of scapegoating and cultural antagonism that framed colonial governance.
Internal Conflict and the Legacy of Colonial Rule
The podcast discusses the internal revolts against Spanish colonial authority during the British invasion of Manila, which revealed the fragility of colonial control. Initial protests advocating for relief from tribute escalated into organized revolts led by figures like Diego Silang, indicating widespread discontent with colonial rule. Interestingly, rebels utilized the same anti-piracy tactics employed by Spanish loyalists, presenting a transformation of colonial structures for anti-colonial purposes. The interplay between indigenous resistance and imperial resilience speaks to the complexities of colonial governance that would shape the Philippines until the late 19th century.
Piracy and the Making of the Spanish Pacific World(University of Pennsylvania Press, 2024) offers a new interpretation of Spanish colonial rule in the Philippine islands. Drawing on the rich archives of Spain’s Asian empire, Dr. Kristie Patricia Flannery reveals that Spanish colonial officials and Catholic missionaries forged alliances with Indigenous Filipinos and Chinese migrant settlers in the Southeast Asian archipelago to wage war against waves of pirates, including massive Chinese pirate fleets, Muslim pirates from the Sulu Zone, and even the British fleet that attacked at the height of the Seven Years’ War. Anti-piracy alliances made Spanish colonial rule resilient to both external shocks and internal revolts that shook the colony to its core.
This revisionist study complicates the assumption that empire was imposed on Filipinos with brute force alone. Rather, anti-piracy also shaped the politics of belonging in the colonial Philippines. Real and imagined pirate threats especially influenced the fate and fortunes of Chinese migrants in the islands. They triggered genocidal massacres of the Chinese at some junctures, and at others facilitated Chinese integration into the Catholic nation as loyal vassals.
Piracy and the Making of the Spanish Pacific World demonstrates that piracy is key to explaining the surprising longevity of Spain’s Asian empire, which, unlike Spanish colonial rule in the Americas, survived the Age of Revolutions and endured almost to the end of the nineteenth century. Moreover, it offers important new insight into piracy’s impact on the trajectory of globalisation and European imperial expansion in maritime Asia.
This interview was conducted by Dr. Miranda Melcher whose new book focuses on post-conflict military integration, understanding treaty negotiation and implementation in civil war contexts, with qualitative analysis of the Angolan and Mozambican civil wars.