Rachel Louise Snyder, a journalist and author of "No Visible Bruises," dives into the troubling realities of women incarcerated for homicide. She discusses a striking statistic: 20% of these women killed their abusive partners. Snyder highlights the failures of self-defense laws in protecting victims and advocates for much-needed reforms. Through powerful anecdotes, she reveals the harrowing journey of women trapped in cycles of violence, ultimately calling for a justice system that truly understands and defends vulnerable women.
Around 20% of incarcerated women for homicide killed their abusive partners, highlighting the intersection of domestic violence and legal consequences.
Self-defense laws in the U.S. often fail to protect women from long-term abuse, necessitating reform to better address their unique situations.
Deep dives
Connection Between Domestic Violence and Homicide
Research reveals a significant intersection between domestic violence and homicide convictions among incarcerated women. Approximately 20% of women convicted of homicide had killed their abusive partners, whereas many others experienced abuse, which coerced them into criminal actions. Examples include women being forced to participate in covering up crimes or threatened to commit other violent acts against others. This underscores the complexity of their situations and suggests that many may have turned to violence as a desperate response to ongoing victimization.
Flaws in Self-Defense Laws
Self-defense laws in the U.S. are largely designed around scenarios involving men, neglecting the realities faced by women in abusive relationships. The concept of 'imminence' is a critical issue, as laws require an immediate threat before action can be justified, which often fails to consider the prolonged patterns of abuse that women experience. Anecdotal cases, like that of Anita Ford, illustrate how women may be denied justice simply because their situation did not fit the narrow parameters of self-defense set by the law. This legal framework often leads to further victimization of women who act to protect themselves but face severe punishment instead.
Cultural Shifts and Legal Reforms
The podcast discusses not only the need for reform in self-defense laws but the broader cultural changes necessary to support victims of domestic violence. Comparisons are drawn with other countries, such as Canada, which have successfully adjusted their legal systems to better protect women, acknowledging the unique contexts of domestic abuse. Despite concerns about potential misuse of these reforms, evidence suggests that the implementation of supportive measures, like the Violence Against Women Act, can lead to significant decreases in domestic violence-related deaths. Engaging in these important discussions about law and culture is essential for creating a safer environment for women confronting abuse.
A survey of people incarcerated in California found that 20 percent of women in for homicide had killed their abusive partners. How have self-defense laws failed women in abusive relationships—and how can they be reformed to save lives?
Want more What Next? Join Slate Plus to unlock full, ad-free access to What Next and all your other favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the What Next show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.