This week dives into the latest legal drama surrounding Michael Avenatti and Rudy Giuliani's struggles with defamation claims. It sheds light on the Central Park Five lawsuit against Donald Trump, highlighting the consequences of false accusations. There's a discussion on the complexities of judicial neutrality in politically charged cases, plus critiques of recent media portrayals of controversial figures. Explore the murky waters of factual claims versus opinions in defamation cases, showcasing the legal dilemmas in today’s media landscape.
Michael Avenatti's favorable Ninth Circuit ruling on his sentencing highlights flaws in judicial calculations amid serious fraud convictions.
Ongoing defamation lawsuits involving Rudy Giuliani and the Central Park Five exemplify the intersection of political rhetoric and legal accountability.
Deep dives
Michael Avenatti's Sentencing Developments
Michael Avenatti's sentencing has been thrown out by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals due to errors made in calculating his sentence, which initially totaled 14 years for multiple fraud convictions. The court found that the sentencing judge improperly added an obstruction of justice enhancement and failed to give Avenatti credit for the legal work he completed that benefited his clients. Avenatti argued that the money he received as permission for his legal services should not count against him as a loss, and the appeals court agreed with this perspective. While this ruling could lead to a reduced sentence, the judge ultimately retains the discretion to set a new sentence and could opt to impose a similar or even higher sentence based on other factors.
Defamation Lawsuits Against Political Figures
In recent developments, two notable defamation lawsuits have emerged, one involving Laura Loomer suing Bill Maher for suggesting a romantic affair between her and Donald Trump, and the other concerning the Central Park Five suing Trump for mischaracterizing their pleas in relation to a historic crime. Loomer's case is perceived as more of a publicity stunt given her legal team's questionable reputation and the satirical context of Maher's platform, which often makes hyperbolic statements. Meanwhile, the Central Park Five are contradicting Trump's assertions that they pleaded guilty to a crime; they maintain their innocence, and the lawsuit focuses on the falsehood of his claims. These cases illustrate the contentious and often absurd nature of political discourse, evolving into legal battles over defamation that highlight reputational stakes.
Rudy Giuliani and Ryan Salami's Legal Troubles
Rudy Giuliani faces a court order to hand over assets to election workers he defamed, reflecting the ongoing repercussions of his controversial statements during and after the election. In a related case, Ryan Salami, a former executive at FTX, has been sentenced to seven and a half years for campaign finance violations and alleges that prosecutors reneged on a deal to spare his girlfriend from prosecution. Salami's claims have been met with skepticism regarding the credibility of his story about plea negotiations. The discussions reveal the complexities of legal agreements and the often murky ethics of prosecutorial strategies, as Salami's legal troubles unfold amid the broader fallout from the FTX scandal.
For all listeners, we have updates this week on Michael Avenatti, Aileen Cannon, Laura Loomer and Bill Maher. Our valued paying subscribers (thank you for your support!) will also hear about: the Central Park Five lawsuit against Donald Trump, Rudy Giuliani being ordered to hand over assets to the election workers he defamed, FTX defendant Ryan Salame, who alleges (dubiously) that federal prosecutors double-crossed him and his girlfriend, and Ron DeSantis ordering Florida television stations to stop airing commercials for a pro-choice ballot measure.
Upgrade your subscription at serioustrouble.show (if you haven't already) to get the full episode.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode