
The Remnant with Jonah Goldberg What’s Wrong with France? | Interview: Thomas Chatterton Williams
29 snips
Oct 28, 2026 Thomas Chatterton Williams, an Atlantic staff writer and cultural critic, joins a wide-ranging conversation about France’s unrest. They explore failing schools, destructive protests, bloated welfare spending, pensions, anti-capitalist envy, and the symbolism of Palestine. The discussion turns to Macron’s failed center, Marine Le Pen, Jean-Luc Mélenchon, migration, radical Islam, immigrant entrepreneurship, and the uncertain future of the Fifth Republic.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
France Blames Capitalism For Its Statism
- France already has an enormous welfare state, yet protesters blame capitalism and demand still more spending.
- Government consumes nearly 60% of GDP, while persistent deficits and expanding benefits produce a ratchet toward more statism.
France’s Welfare State Cannibalizes Its Young
- French politics offers no meaningful fiscal-conservative alternative because both extremes promise earlier retirement and greater benefits.
- The state funds long retirements by diverting resources from education and younger generations, making reform politically explosive.
The Palestinian Flag Became The Omni-Cause Symbol
- The Palestinian flag functions internationally as a symbol of solidarity with the oppressed rather than a focused response to French foreign policy.
- Protesters use it as shorthand for an entire ideological package, even when France has already supported Palestinian causes.




