Dateline NBC A dentist on trial for poisoning his wife. And detectives' doubts about the case of a Virginia dad accused of conspiring with his au pair.
Jul 17, 2025
Marianne O'Donnell, a seasoned Dateline producer, takes listeners inside the courtroom drama of a dentist accused of poisoning his wife. She reveals chilling details, including security footage that could shift the trial's outcome. The episode also dives into the controversial case of Brendan Banfield, who is charged with plotting to kill his wife with the help of an au pair, and the conflicting narratives that challenge the prosecution's case. O'Donnell shares insights on courtroom tactics and the complexities faced by detectives.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Craig's Alleged Poisoning Method
- James Craig allegedly poisoned his wife using potassium cyanide and tetrahydrosaline found in eye drops.
- Surveillance footage and Google searches suggest deliberate planning of the murder.
Alleged Prison Schemes of James Craig
- James Craig allegedly attempted to fabricate evidence suggesting his wife’s suicide from prison.
- He also tried to solicit murder of the lead investigator, indicating premeditation beyond the initial crime.
Forensics Doubts Catfishing Theory
- The digital forensics detective found that it was the murder victim Christine who likely arranged the meeting that led to her killing.
- Evidence contradicted the prosecution's theory of a catfishing plot by her husband and the au pair.