Negative Psychoanalysis - Death, Depression, and Suffering with Julie Reshe
Dec 4, 2024
auto_awesome
Julie Reshe, a Ukrainian-born philosopher and negative psychoanalyst, dives deep into the often-overlooked role of negativity in human experience. She critiques traditional psychology, encouraging a reassessment of depression and anxiety not as failures, but integral to our existence. Reshe explores the paradox of societal happiness pressure, linking it to increased unhappiness, and advocates for authentic connections through shared negative experiences. Her insights on negative psychoanalysis offer a refreshing perspective on embracing our emotional complexities.
Negative psychoanalysis emphasizes the acceptance of depression and anxiety as meaningful human experiences rather than aberrations to be corrected.
The discussion critiques societal pressures for constant positivity, framing suffering as an integral aspect of existence deserving recognition and reflection.
Deep dives
Reappropriating Negativity
The concept of negative psychoanalysis is presented as a way to reclaim the notion of negativity within human existence. Traditional therapeutic frameworks often alienate negative states such as depression, anxiety, and suicidal thoughts, viewing them as aberrations. In contrast, negative psychoanalysis encourages the acceptance of these states as inherently human experiences that hold significant meaning. This reappropriation is considered a failure, however, as true negativity resists complete ownership, making it challenging to fully embrace its qualities.
Language and the Perception of Negativity
The evolution of language surrounding mental health has shifted the way negativity is perceived and processed. Terms like 'depression' have become diagnostic labels that perpetuate feelings of inadequacy and the need for correction, unlike the more philosophically rich notion of 'melancholia.' By juxtaposing these terms, it is argued that melancholia carries a historical understanding that aligns better with profound human experiences, thus fostering a healthier discussion about emotional struggles. The stigmatisation embedded in contemporary terminology often limits an individual's ability to relate to their negative feelings without a sense of shame or inadequacy.
Critique of Positivity and Mental Health Approaches
The podcast scrutinizes societal pressures that demand constant positivity, equating happiness with success and productivity. This dichotomy creates a stigmatized view of those experiencing depression or negative states, often framing them as weak or inadequate. The impact of this positive bias, especially among mental health professionals, can lead to a lack of genuine understanding and empathy for individuals facing these struggles. The conversation invites a reconsideration of how to engage with negativity not as a problem to be fixed, but as a legitimate human experience worthy of recognition and reflection.
Human Existence and the Nature of Suffering
The discussion positions human existence within a framework of inherent suffering and acknowledges the paradox of consciousness. Rather than viewing suffering solely as a negative phenomenon, it suggests that the acceptance of this suffering can foster a deeper connection with oneself and others. There is a critical examination of concepts like anti-natalism, questioning whether the advent of new life inherently brings suffering or if it encompasses a broader understanding of existence's tragic nature. Ultimately, the conversation challenges listeners to reframe their understanding of life’s suffering as a fundamental part of the human experience, rather than a condition to escape.
Julie Reshe is a Ukrainian-born philosopher, a practicing negative
psychoanalyst, and a public intellectual. She is currently a visiting
professor at University College Cork and University College Dublin. She
is also a Director of the Institute of Psychoanalysis at the Global
Centre for Advanced Studies.
Reshe's site: https://www.juliereshe.com
Book link: https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-031-31201-4
---Become part of the Hermitix community:Hermitix Twitter - / hermitixpodcast Support Hermitix:Patreon - / hermitix Donations: - https://www.paypal.me/hermitixpodHermitix Merchandise - http://teespring.com/stores/hermitix-2Bitcoin Donation Address: 3LAGEKBXEuE2pgc4oubExGTWtrKPuXDDLKEthereum Donation Address: 0x31e2a4a31B8563B8d238eC086daE9
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode