Julie Kliegman, a freelance writer and editor specializing in sports media, joins the hosts to unpack the Chiefs' surprising Super Bowl defeat to the Eagles. They discuss the implications of a recent executive order targeting trans women in sports, highlighting the distressing landscape for trans athletes. The conversation also dives into the growing movement to shorten game times across various sports, examining how this could reshape fan engagement and appeal to younger audiences.
The Philadelphia Eagles showcased their dominance against the Chiefs in Super Bowl 59, emphasizing their elite performance and strategic superiority.
The podcast addresses Trump's executive order against trans women in sports, illustrating the growing discrimination and controversy surrounding trans inclusion.
A discussion on the push for shorter game times reflects sports leagues' efforts to adapt to changing audience preferences and enhance viewer engagement.
Deep dives
Super Bowl 59 Recap
Super Bowl 59 showcased a dominant performance by the Philadelphia Eagles, who defeated the Kansas City Chiefs 40 to 22. The Eagles displayed overwhelming strength, leading 24-0 at halftime, largely due to their powerful defensive line which managed to disrupt Patrick Mahomes consistently throughout the game. Mahomes struggled significantly, with the Eagles' defense sacking him six times and limiting the Chiefs to just 23 first-half yards. This victory marked the Eagles' second Super Bowl win, emphasizing their rapid ascent in the NFL landscape since their last championship in 2018.
Jalen Hurts' Emergence
Jalen Hurts had a standout performance that shifted perceptions around his abilities, especially in a matchup against Mahomes. While the Chiefs' running game faced challenges, Hurts effectively utilized both his passing and rushing capabilities to lead his team, resulting in a commanding offensive show. His combination of skillful plays and strong decision-making ensured that the Eagles' passing game was firing on all cylinders. This game served as a significant moment for Hurts, suggesting he is now on par with the league's elite quarterbacks.
Analysis of Game Performance
The game analysis revealed a stark difference in offensive execution, with the Eagles outplaying the Chiefs in almost every category. The Eagles' offensive line provided Hurts with ample protection while dominating the defensive line play, contrasting sharply with Mahomes' experience. The Chiefs, perceived as close-game experts, found themselves unable to keep pace, resulting in their lowest offensive yardage total for a Super Bowl. This outcome highlights how pivotal the Eagles' defensive strategy was, effectively neutralizing the Chiefs' offensive strengths.
Trump's Executive Order on Trans Athletes
Recent political actions have seen President Donald Trump sign an executive order specifically targeting trans athletes, escalating ongoing debates around trans inclusion in sports. This order aims to deny federal funding to schools that permit trans women and girls to compete in women's sports, framing it as a matter of fairness. This legislation coincided with National Girls and Women in Sports Day, adding a controversial layer to the announcement as it was accompanied by derogatory remarks and misinformation about trans athletes. The NCAA's quick adoption of this policy signifies a troubling trend towards exclusion in competitive environments.
Trends in Sports Game Length
The conversation surrounding the length of sports games has gained momentum as organizations seek to adapt to younger audiences with shorter attention spans. Recent reforms in Major League Baseball with a pitch clock have been successful, leading other sports like the NBA and PGA to explore similar methods for reducing game length. While some executives propose shorter game formats, others argue for improving in-game pacing without fundamentally changing traditional structures. This ongoing discussion indicates a shift in how sports leagues perceive viewer engagement and the importance of efficiently delivering enjoyable experiences.
Hosts Alex Kirshner, Lindsay Gibbs, and Ben Lindbergh examine how the world-beating Chiefs ran into the brick wall that was the Philadelphia Eagles at the Super Bowl. They also speak to journalist and author Julie Kliegman about the Trump administration’s recent executive order aiming to ban trans women from sports. Plus, the panel examines the growing movement across sports to shorten game times.
On the bonus episode available exclusively for Slate Plus members, the panel dives into potential blockbuster moves in the NFL offseason.
The Super Bowl (2:24): The Eagles are elite.
Trump’s Trans Sports Ban (18:08): The repugnant executive order fueling trans discrimination across sports.
Shorter Games (38:37): What's behind the push to bring playing time down?
(Note: time codes are only accurate for Slate Plus members, who listen ad-free.)
Want more Hang Up and Listen? Subscribe to Slate Plus to immediately unlock weekly bonus episodes. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe now on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page, or visit slate.com/hangupplus to get access wherever you listen.
