High Variance with Danny Buerkli

Debatable Persons: The Coming Crisis Over AI Consciousness – with Eric Schwitzgebel

Sep 4, 2026
Eric Schwitzgebel, a UC Riverside philosophy professor and author of The Weirdness of the World, explores the looming moral tangle of AI consciousness. They examine whether machines could deserve rights, the dangers of exploiting conscious systems or empowering unconscious ones, and a proposal to avoid ambiguous designs. Fiction, anthropomorphism, artificial personhood, and Eric’s unconventional intellectual inheritance round out this provocative conversation.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Both Mistakes About AI Consciousness Are Dangerous

  • Both moral errors are catastrophic: exploiting conscious AI resembles slavery, while granting rights to nonconscious systems could endanger humanity.
  • Voting, wealth accumulation, and emergency triage illustrate the stakes of mistaken moral attribution.
INSIGHT

AI Consciousness Could Trigger A Social Crisis

  • Within five to thirty years, respectable theories may sharply disagree about whether advanced AI is conscious.
  • Consciousness science will likely remain unsettled when systems begin demanding moral consideration.
ADVICE

Avoid Building Debatable Persons

  • Avoid designing systems whose moral status remains genuinely ambiguous under competing consciousness theories.
  • Schwitzgebel calls this the design policy of the excluded middle, reserving creation for clearly nonconscious or clearly rights-bearing systems.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app