Matthew Yglesias, a Bloomberg columnist and author of 'Slow Boring,' offers a critical look at the future of Democratic politics. He reflects on the missteps of identity politics and the complex challenges of Biden's presidency amidst a potential second Trump term. The discussion also delves into immigration policy, wealth inequality, and the importance of focusing on actions over identities. Yglesias advocates for economic coherence while addressing social dysfunction, urging a thoughtful approach to climate change and the balancing of justice in policing.
Matthew Iglesias critiques the Democratic Party's drift from core values and suggests a return to foundational principles to reconnect with voters.
Iglesias highlights the complexities of identity politics, emphasizing a need for clearer policies to address issues like crime and policing.
The podcast underscores the risks of language policing in political discourse, advocating for a more open conversation on contentious topics.
Deep dives
Matthew Iglesias's Background in Journalism
Matthew Iglesias discusses his journey in journalism, beginning with blogging during college before graduating to work for a progressive magazine called The American Prospect. His career primarily revolves around digital journalism focused on politics in Washington, D.C., including a significant tenure at Vox.com. After leaving Vox about four years prior to the conversation, he embarked on a personal venture through Substack, influenced by a feeling of disconnection from progressive politics around 2020. Iglesias identifies himself as a liberal and a Democrat, yet he expresses unease about the shifts within the party and a desire for course corrections in its approach.
Democratic Party's Disconnection from Mainstream Values
Iglesias critiques the Democratic Party's drift from mainstream cultural and moral values, suggesting that this shift has led to a disconnect with ordinary Americans. He emphasizes that the party has increasingly focused on identity politics and complex, sometimes convoluted ideas at the expense of core Democratic values such as protecting vulnerable populations. The conversation highlights a need for the party to revisit its foundational principles to reconnect with the electorate's needs. Iglesias also acknowledges his own potential misalignment with mainstream sentiments, illustrating his concerns about the party's current trajectory.
The Complexities of Identity Politics
The discussion pivots to the complexities and evolution of identity politics, with Iglesias reflecting on his shifting views since earlier controversies surrounding political correctness. He acknowledges previous underestimations of the challenges posed by identity politics on issues such as crime and police brutality. Iglesias argues that Democrats have struggled to articulate coherent policies on these critical issues, suggesting that many have come to realize the missteps that have occurred over the years. The dialogue underscores the necessity of recalibrating the conversation around identity to restore productive political discourse within the party.
Justice and the Daniel Penny Incident
Iglesias examines the controversial case involving Daniel Penny, who was acquitted after defending himself against a perceived threat on a subway. He expresses confusion over the disparate reactions from left-leaning media and commentators, who often equate cases of self-defense with acts of vigilante justice. Iglesias argues that the coverage surrounding Penny's case reflects deeper issues of bias and misjudgment among progressives regarding self-defense and public safety. This case highlights the challenges facing the Democratic Party in navigating complex narratives about crime and race.
Rethinking Race and Policing Discussions
In discussing race and policing, Iglesias advocates for a civil discourse that prioritizes character over race in evaluating individuals' actions. He emphasizes the importance of treating crime and policing issues with the seriousness they warrant, rather than exclusively through the lens of racial identity. Iglesias believes that a focus on individual actions and accountability should take precedence in law enforcement discussions, arguing that community safety must be prioritized. By framing the conversation around character and actions, he signals a move away from identity-based interpretations that often polarize discussions.
The Role of Politeness and Language Policing
Iglesias raises concerns about the current trends of language policing that can stifle open discourse and intellectual engagement. He argues that obsessive monitoring of language can alienate people and deteriorate the quality of discussions surrounding important issues. While acknowledging the value of politeness, he notes that the increasing sensitivity to language hinders productive conversations about complex, often contentious topics. This dynamic, Iglesias contends, must be addressed to foster an environment conducive to honest discourse and problem-solving.
Sam Harris speaks with Matthew Yglesias about the future of Democratic politics. They discuss where the Democrats went wrong, the failure of identity politics, the Left’s reaction to the Daniel Penny case, what a second Trump term might look like, immigration and the border, gender and racial disparities in crime, wealth inequality, Matthew’s “nine principles for a common sense Democrat comeback,” and other topics.
Matthew Yglesias is a columnist for Bloomberg and author of the newsletter Slow Boring. He has also written for The American Prospect, The Atlantic, and Slate. He co-founded Vox in 2014.
Learning how to train your mind is the single greatest investment you can make in life. That’s why Sam Harris created the Waking Up app. From rational mindfulness practice to lessons on some of life’s most important topics, join Sam as he demystifies the practice of meditation and explores the theory behind it.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
