Life after Life: Striving with Problems in a Good Way with Alva Noë
Nov 7, 2024
auto_awesome
Alva Noë, a renowned Professor of Philosophy at UC Berkeley, dives into a thought-provoking dialogue on self-awareness and identity. He explores the profound connection between love and personal growth, emphasizing the evolving nature of relationships. The conversation highlights the interplay of consciousness, art, and perception, challenging traditional views on sensory experiences. From the dynamics of mass gatherings to the importance of expressing self through art, Noë invites listeners to rethink how they navigate existence, bridging philosophy and lived experience.
Emotions, especially love, are dynamic processes that reshape our identities and transform challenges into opportunities for growth.
Work is portrayed as an essential mode of being that enriches our understanding and requires continuous effort in relationships.
Perception extends beyond sight, emphasizing an embodied experience that fosters deeper connections through active engagement with our surroundings.
Deep dives
Emotions as Life Processes
Emotions, particularly love, are portrayed as dynamic life processes rather than static states. They play a key role in shaping our identities and experiences, functioning as mechanisms that continuously remake us. This perspective suggests that problems we encounter in relationships or life circumstances are actually opportunities for reorganizing our understanding and selves. By embracing the fluidity of our emotions, we can learn to navigate life's challenges more effectively, recognizing the transformative potential inherent in our emotional experiences.
The Significance of Work and Striving
The concept of work is framed as a fundamental mode of being that is intrinsically linked to love and human connection. It is suggested that to truly understand ourselves and others, we must engage deeply in the act of knowing, which requires strife and effort. Being present in relationships does not come effortlessly; it demands ongoing work and striving to foster intimacy. This understanding positions our labor—whether in personal relationships, creative endeavors, or intellectual pursuits—as an essential element in achieving fulfillment and deeper connections.
Seeing and Perception Beyond Vision
The act of seeing is redefined to encompass more than mere visual observation, suggesting that perception is an embodied experience that engages all our senses. This broader understanding emphasizes that perception transcends physical sight, inviting exploration through touch, movement, and emotional engagement. By considering perceptions as actions, we open pathways to experiencing the world and each other in more profound ways. This approach highlights the importance of actively engaging with our surroundings to gain richer insights into ourselves and the relationships we build.
The Interconnectedness of Art, Philosophy, and Human Experience
Art and philosophy are presented as intertwined domains that facilitate our understanding of consciousness and our place in the world. Through artistic expression and philosophical inquiry, we encounter opportunities that prompt us to reevaluate our habits, identities, and ways of being. This entanglement enables us to engage in a continuous process of reorganization, finding new meanings and perspectives in our interactions. Recognizing the role of creativity in shaping our consciousness allows for a richer navigation of the complexities of life and relationships.
Paradox as a Tool for Understanding
Embracing paradox is essential for grasping the multifaceted nature of human existence and relationships. The notion that our understanding can encompass conflicting ideas—such as the coexistence of free will and determinism—offers a more nuanced view of our experiences. This perspective also extends to our reasoning and emotional responses, establishing that they are not mutually exclusive but rather, intertwined. By fostering spaces for open dialogue and reflection on these dualities, we improve our ability to relate to one another and navigate life's complexities.
Alva Noë is Professor of Philosophy, and Chair of the Department of Philosophy, at the University of California, Berkeley, where he is also a member of the Center for New Media, and the Institute for Cognitive and Brain Sciences. Professor Noë is a 2012 recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship and a 2018 recipient of the Judd Hume Prize in Advanced Visual Studies. Until the end of 2024, he is an Einstein Visiting Fellow at the Free University in Berlin. He is the author of Action in Perception (2004), Out of Our Heads: Why You Are Not Your Brain and Other Lessons from the Biology of Consciousness (2009), Varieties of Presence (2012), Strange Tools: Art and Human Nature (2015), Infinite Baseball: Notes from a Philosopher at the Ballpark (2019), and Learning To Look: Dispatches from the Art World (2022). His latest book is The Entanglement: How Art and Philosophy Make Us What We Are (2023). https://www.alvanoe.com/
In this conversation, Andrea and Alva engage in an enlightening journey together through the realms of philosophy, neuroscience, and the arts, opening the work Noë has done and exploring its themes of self-awareness, identity, action and perception.
With insights from influential thinkers and doers like Vico, Dreyfus, Cezanne, Merleau-Ponty, and Noë himself, this conversation delves into the profound connections between love, work, and personal development and becomes a poetic meditation on meaning and connection. Per usual in Love and Philosophy, we find the motif of the loop that never quite returns to where it started, the dynamic entanglement of life, and how this gets conveyed through writing and language. Alva and Andrea explore the complexities of presence, the role of habits and societal structures, and the evolving understanding of vision and perception. The conversation also shows how interdisciplinary approaches and transformative literature shape our identities and consciousness from childhood on, and ultimately offers a balanced, holistic view of the human experience as difficult but worth it. Tune in for a thought-provoking discourse on the power of performance and the representation of self, including what tricky words like 'representation' and 'agency' might really be pointing at within the intricate dance of art and philosophy. Love and Philosophy Substack www.loveandphilosophy.com