Judith Butler Will Not Co-Sign Israel’s Alibi for Genocide
May 1, 2024
auto_awesome
Famed American philosopher Judith Butler discusses the controversy surrounding their remarks on Hamas and armed resistance in Israel. Topics include crackdowns on student protests, academic freedom, and navigating the complexities of condemning violence while understanding historical context in the Israel-Palestine conflict.
Judith Butler views Hamas-led operations as armed resistance in the historical context, sparking controversy and criticism from media in Europe and Israel.
The suppression of protests and free speech on college campuses reflects a broader pattern of restricting dissenting voices, showcasing varying commitments to preserving freedom of expression.
Deep dives
Examining the Political Situation in Israel and Gaza
Netanyahu's readiness for a full-scale invasion of Rafah showcases his commitment to prolonging the war despite opportunities for peace deals. The discussion highlights how the war is not solely about hostages, with Netanyahu seemingly obstructing ongoing negotiations and potentially avoiding legal troubles by extending the conflict. Reports of the International Criminal Court's involvement and Netanyahu's efforts to prevent potential indictments add complexity to the political landscape.
Challenges of Free Speech on College Campuses
Instances of suppressing protests and free speech on college campuses, including violent crackdowns, reveal a broader pattern of restricting dissenting voices. The summary touches on the incidents at Emory University and the use of police force to disrupt student protests. Differences in university presidents' responses to such protests showcase varying degrees of commitment to preserving freedom of expression.
The Influence of Youth Activism on Palestine Solidarity
The scale and scope of protests for Palestine highlight generational shifts in how younger individuals perceive and engage with the Israel-Palestine conflict. The mobilization, particularly on college campuses, reflects a growing clarity and conviction among the youth regarding the atrocities and oppression faced by Palestinians. The engagement with history, Zionism, occupation, and apartheid contributes to a more informed and vocal stance on justice and equality.
Challenges of Discussing Israel-Palestine Critically in Europe
The episode delves into the challenges faced in Europe, especially in Germany, regarding discussions on Israel-Palestine and the suppression of critical viewpoints. Legal repercussions, including arrests for using historical terms to describe current events in Gaza, underscore the precarious situation of free speech and democracy. The weaponization of laws against residents expressing dissent raises concerns about far-right influences and the stifling of open dialogue and debate.
Last month, the famed American philosopher and gender studies scholar Judith Butler was thrust into the center of a controversy after remarks Butler made about the October 7 attacks in Israel. A longtime critic of Zionism and Israel’s war against the Palestinians, Butler had condemned the attacks in the immediate aftermath. But at a March roundtable in France, Butler offered a historical context for the Hamas-led operations and stated that the attacks constituted armed resistance. The blowback was swift, and Butler was criticized in media outlets across Europe and in Israel. This week on Intercepted, Butler discusses the controversy and their position on Hamas, Israel, and crackdowns on student protests.
Butler is currently a Distinguished Professor at UC Berkeley’s Graduate School. They are the author of several books, including “The Force of Nonviolence: An Ethico-Political Bind,” “Parting Ways: Jewishness and the Critique of Zionism,” and most recently, “Who's Afraid of Gender?”
If you’d like to support our work, go to theintercept.com/join, where your donation, no matter what the amount, makes a real difference.
And if you haven’t already, please subscribe to the show so you can hear it every week. And please go and leave us a rating or a review — it helps people find the show. If you want to give us additional feedback, email us at Podcasts@theintercept.com.