My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark 509 - Let Me Corrupt You
Dec 4, 2025
Dive into the eerie mystery surrounding Phoebe Handsjuk's puzzling death, marked by questionable police work and unsettling details that raise more questions than answers. Meanwhile, journey through the haunting tale of the SS Edmund Fitzgerald, where a ferocious storm brings tragedy and loss as the ship vanishes without a trace. With personal insights, chilling theories, and a sprinkle of humor, this episode captivates fans of true crime and maritime history alike.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Body Found In Refuse Room
- Phoebe Handsjuk was found in the building refuse room after falling feet-first down a 12th-floor garbage chute.
- Melbourne police initially treated the scene as a suicide and missed basic investigative steps like checking for signs of life.
Boyfriend With Powerful Family
- Phoebe was 24 and living with a 45-year-old boyfriend named Anthony who had prominent judicial family connections.
- The boyfriend's family influence later complicated access to lawyers and investigators.
Confusing Final Messages And Phones
- Phoebe sent a strange group text while hungover mentioning going to hospital and tomato soup, which alarmed family.
- Confusion increased because calls around that time occurred from her boyfriend's phone, not hers.