Walk On: The Athletic FC's Liverpool show Is the title defence over already?
Nov 10, 2025
James Pearce, Liverpool correspondent known for his match insights, joins the discussion but bows out mid-show due to a sore throat. The panel dives into Liverpool's 3-0 defeat at Manchester City and debates the controversial disallowed goal by Virgil van Dijk. They analyze tactical failures and question the impact of VAR on the matchday experience. With Liverpool eight points adrift, discussions turn to whether the title defense is over and if they should focus on the Champions League instead.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Etihad Performance Was Uncharacteristically Passive
- Liverpool produced a bloodless, underprepared performance at the Etihad and were second best across the pitch.
- Simon Hughes says City dominated early and Liverpool never found a tactical response.
Matchday Grimness And A Podcast Substitution
- James Pearce described the matchday experience as "grim" after rain and illness disrupted his reporting.
- Tony and Simon humorously subbed him off the podcast, bringing on Andy Jones as a super-sub.
Offside Call Felt Ambiguous In Slow Motion
- The Van Dijk header was disallowed for offside, but slow-motion review shows the keeper had already committed.
- Si and Tony disagree over rule clarity and whether Robertson truly influenced the save.