In this gripping discussion, hacker Chris Montero uncovers a chilling dark web kill list and alerts journalist Carl Miller to its implications. They explore the harrowing case of Amy Allwine, whose name appeared on the list, raising disturbing questions about law enforcement's response. Delving into the mystery of a suburban crime scene and the interplay between hackers and journalists, Chris shares the urgent fight against online assassination markets and the ethical dilemmas that come with such powerful knowledge.
Detective McAllister's investigation unveiled significant discrepancies in a reported suicide, leading to suspicions of foul play and eventual homicide.
The discovery of a dark web kill list highlighted the severe and complex nature of online threats and the ethical dilemmas faced by investigators.
Deep dives
The Mysterious Crime Scene
Detective Randy McAllister arrived at the scene of a reported suicide at the Allwine residence, only to find discrepancies that aroused suspicion. Despite initial appearances suggesting that Amy Allwine had taken her own life, the positioning of the gun and the bloody footprints throughout the house hinted at foul play. Investigation revealed a large pool of blood near the master bedroom, prompting McAllister to tape off the scene and seek further forensic analysis. This led to an unraveling investigation tied not only to Amy's death but also to a much larger network of murder plots.
The Web of Threats
As the investigation deepened, it became evident that Amy Allwine was a target on a dark web hitman-for-hire site, where countless death threats were being issued. The person behind Amy's targeting operated under the username DogDayGod, raising chilling implications about the nature of the threats people face online. The investigators discovered that extensive planning had gone into the hit, including detailed personal information about Amy and a payment of over $5,000 made in Bitcoin for her assassination. Through these revelations, it became clear that the nature of internet-based threats was far more serious than initially perceived.
Uncovering the Culprit
Detective McAllister's investigation began focusing on those closest to Amy, particularly her husband, Stephen, as the evidence against him accumulated. Stephen’s suspicious behavior and the discovery of a recent transaction for Bitcoin suggested a connection to the hit on Amy’s life. Further digital forensics confirmed that the Bitcoin wallet used for the hit was indeed linked to Stephen, affirming that he was the individual behind the veiled threats. This mounting evidence culminated in Stephen's arrest, solidifying the notion that personal motives often drive the darkest intentions.
Facing Ethical Dilemmas
With the discovery of the kill list, journalists and investigators faced the daunting task of navigating the ethical implications of their findings. The list revealed numerous threats against innocent individuals, raising urgent questions about how to proceed without putting more lives at risk. Reporting the threats to authorities proved problematic, as law enforcement appeared under-resourced and overwhelmed by the digital nature of the crimes. This tension between journalistic responsibility and the need for immediate action confronted the investigators with a moral dilemma regarding their next steps in addressing the dangerous world of online assassination threats.
Binge episodes 1-6 and weekly new episodes of Kill List by signing up for Wondery+ on Apple or Spotify.
A frantic 911 call sparks an investigation into a suspicious death. The case takes an unexpected turn when the victim’s name is discovered among those on a dark net kill list.
Listener note: This episode contains references to suicide. If you have been affected by this episode you can find additional resources here:
Follow the Kill List on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. You can binge all episodes early and ad-free on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting www.wondery.com/links/kill-list now.