Guests nic and Kobi delve into the troubling intersection of Mormonism and settler colonialism. They share personal journeys and discuss how foundational narratives of the church impact Indigenous populations. The duo critiques the church's attempts to validate its beliefs through Mesoamerican archaeology and the resulting cultural damage. They also address online harassment faced by progressive Mormons and the church's evolving stance on race and LGBTQ+ issues, emphasizing the importance of accountability and community in navigating their identities.
Nick and Kobi's journey reflects a deeper quest for identity, uncovering the historical complexities of their Mormon heritage.
The podcast connects Mormonism to settler colonialism, revealing how it historically justified land acquisition at the expense of indigenous peoples.
Discussions on the systemic issues within the Mormon Church highlight the challenges of reform versus the stronghold of traditional ideologies.
Deep dives
Founders' Perspectives on Mormonism's Impact
The founders of Unsettling Mormonism, Nick and Kobi, provide insights into their backgrounds and motivations for exploring their Mormon roots. Nick, having been raised in a predominantly Mormon family, sought to understand the historical and ideological underpinnings of his upbringing. Kobi, also from a Mormon background, initially distanced themselves from the religion but later found value in revisiting their ancestral roots through research. Their shared journey highlights a quest for identity and understanding, addressing gaps in the education of current and former Mormons regarding the complexities and historical narratives of their faith.
Mormonism: Beliefs and Misconceptions
Mormonism, founded by Joseph Smith in the early 19th century, adheres to the Bible while claiming additional scriptures that recount the history of ancient Israelites in America. A common misconception is that Mormons do not view themselves as Christians, despite their belief in Jesus Christ. The discussion also touches on the debated practice of polygamy, which is no longer accepted in the mainstream church but still shapes perceptions of Mormon society. The conversation emphasizes the need for greater understanding of Mormon beliefs and the cultural context surrounding them.
Mormonism and Settler Colonialism
The episode links Mormonism to broader themes of settler colonialism, highlighting how the religion's narrative positions itself within the historical context of land acquisition and displacement. Mormons viewed their presence in what is now the United States as a fulfillment of divine destiny, claiming lands with little regard for the indigenous peoples already there. Historical references such as the state of Deseret showcase the church's ambitions for political and territorial sovereignty, often at the expense of Native populations. This perspective urges listeners to reconsider the implications of Mormon historical narratives and their consequences for indigenous communities.
The Intersection of Mormonism, Imperialism, and Archaeology
Mormon Church activities extend beyond the U.S., with implications for indigenous people in other countries, particularly in Central America. The pursuit of archaeological evidence to validate the Book of Mormon has led to exploitative practices reminiscent of colonialism, positioning indigenous ruins as contentious sites. The church mobilizes financial and political resources to promote their interests in various nations, shaping local economies and cultural narratives. This complex relationship raises critical questions about the church's responsibilities towards impacted populations and their need for authentic representation.
Confronting the Power Dynamics Within Mormonism
The conversation highlights the challenges faced by individuals within the Mormon Church who seek to address its systemic issues. While some members feel a strong community connection, the church's organizational structure can perpetuate problematic ideologies, such as white supremacy and colonialism. Calls for reform face resistance from established power dynamics that often prioritize tradition and conservative values over inclusivity. The ongoing dialogue emphasizes the necessity of critiquing the institution while fostering spaces for individual experiences and community solidarity outside of the church's confines.
TRN Podcast co-hosts Nick Estes (@nickwestes) and Jen Marley (@JenMarley1680) talk to nic and Kobi about the settler colonial underpinnings of Mormonism.