Conversations That Matter Everyday Revolutionary or Third Way Remix? A Review of J.D. Greear's Latest Book
6 snips
Nov 20, 2025 A deep dive into J.D. Greear's new book reveals a clash between revolutionary ideals and traditional party lines. The discussion highlights Greear's evolving views on social issues versus maintaining evangelical credibility. Tensions arise over his stance on activism, with critics noting a muddled message on engaging politics. Comparisons to historical figures like MLK and George Whitefield expose inconsistencies in his approach. Ultimately, the conversation questions whether Greear offers genuine renewal or just a polished version of past strategies.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Third-Way Remix As Pastoral Strategy
- J.D. Greear repackages “third-way” thinking: avoid partisan labels while mixing progressive social-justice and conservative personal-morality stances.
- Jon Harris frames this as a strategy to keep churches accessible across political divides but calls it a muddled compromise.
Blame For Youth Drift Debated
- Greear blames evangelical silence on Trump’s moral failures for driving young people to the left.
- Harris contends political calculation, not pastor silence, better explains many voters' choices.
Prioritize Witness Over Party Label
- Avoid overt partisan labeling so a church won’t lose access to half its mission field.
- Prioritize faithful witness over political tribal identity when deciding public stances.
