Matt Martens, a trial lawyer and legal ethics professor, discusses his decision to vote for a third-party candidate from the American Solidarity Party. He delves into the moral complexities Christians face at the ballot box, particularly concerning contentious issues like abortion. The conversation reflects on the relationship between faith and political identity, emphasizing the need for integrity in voting choices. Martens also highlights the evolving political landscape and the feeling of abandonment among traditional party voters.
Voting for a third-party candidate allows Christians to align their votes with personal moral beliefs rather than mainstream political success.
Christians may feel politically homeless due to conflicting traditional party affiliations, yet they can find hope through their theological perspective on governance.
Deep dives
Understanding Government from a Christian Perspective
For Christians, government is viewed through the lens of moral responsibility and justice. Augustine's assertion that governments without justice resemble bands of robbers highlights the necessity of ethical governance. This perspective shapes the belief that the state's power must be wielded justly to protect citizens, particularly the innocent. As citizens, Christians are tasked with determining who is morally worthy to hold governmental power, which guides their electoral choices.
The Case for Third-Party Voting
Voting for a third party can be viewed as a valid expression of one’s moral beliefs rather than a wasted vote. Engaging in third-party or write-in votes allows individuals to align their political actions with their personal convictions without endorsing candidates they deem morally disqualifying. This approach emphasizes the belief that casting a vote should primarily reflect one’s ethical stance on governance rather than merely considering the success of the candidate. Thus, a Christian's choice can be to support someone they believe embodies justice, regardless of mainstream electoral outcomes.
The Moral Disqualification of Major Party Candidates
A significant factor influencing voting decisions among Christians is the moral stance candidates take, particularly on issues like abortion. Many Christians find it difficult to support candidates from the two major parties if they promote policies that they perceive as morally wrong, such as facilitating abortion. This creates a dilemma where, despite political feasibility, the endorsement of a candidate who does not uphold ethical standards can feel complicit in wrongdoing. Consequently, some voters choose candidates who may not have a realistic chance of winning but better align with their moral convictions.
Navigating Despair and Political Homelessness
The current political landscape has left many Christians feeling politically homeless as traditional party affiliations increasingly conflict with personal values. This situation reflects broader cultural shifts that challenge the notion of a party reflecting Christian ethics, leading to feelings of despair about the future of political engagement. However, Christians are encouraged to view their political standing through a theological lens, recognizing their ultimate allegiance lies with God's governance rather than worldly power structures. Thus, despite feelings of marginalization, Christians can maintain hope, drawing strength from their faith rather than relying on political affiliation for meaning or identity.
This is the first episode in our special Stop. Look. Listen. miniseries, which features thoughtful reflections from Christians on who they’re voting for in November’s presidential election.
Matt Martens is voting for a third-party candidate from the American Solidarity Party. He’s a trial lawyer, a former federal prosecutor, a seminary graduate, a legal ethics professor, and an award-winning author. Martens’s writing has appeared in The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, and other outlets, and he has spoken at numerous universities across the country.
Rate and review the show in your podcast app of choice.
Leave a comment in Spotify with your feedback on the discussion.
ABOUT THE BULLETIN:
The Bulletin is a weekly (and sometimes more!) current events show from Christianity Today hosted and moderated by Clarissa Moll, with senior commentary from Russell Moore (Christianity Today’s editor in chief) and Mike Cosper (director, CT Media). Each week, the show explores current events and breaking news and shares a Christian perspective on issues that are shaping our world. We also offer special one-on-one conversations with writers, artists, and thought leaders whose impact on the world brings important significance to a Christian worldview, like Bono, Sharon McMahon, Harrison Scott Key, Frank Bruni, and more.