
The C.S. Lewis podcast #239 Stefan Knibbe: CS Lewis on Freedom, Suffering, and Hell
Dec 8, 2025
Stefan Knibbe, a philosophy and theology graduate, dives deep into C.S. Lewis's complex views on freedom, suffering, and hell. He discusses how Lewis’s thoughts evolved over time and the significant influence of George MacDonald on his theology. Stefan highlights tensions between free will and divine compulsion in works like Till We Have Faces. Discover how Lewis shaped his own faith and preaching style while reflecting on favorite passages that emphasize God's presence over mere explanations.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Early Conversion Sparked By Lewis
- Stefan Knibbe describes encountering C.S. Lewis in ninth grade and being given Mere Christianity, which sparked his faith journey.
- He read Screwtape and felt convicted, beginning a long engagement with Lewis that shaped his beliefs and studies.
Lewis's Theological Shift Over Time
- Knibbe noticed a tonal and theological shift between Lewis's early apologetics and later works like Surprised By Joy and Reflections on the Psalms.
- He sees Lewis moving from argumentative apologetics toward experiential, revelatory emphasis on sin and joy.
Tension Between Freedom And Divine Compulsion
- Knibbe highlights a tension in Lewis between strong human freedom and divine influence or compulsion in conversion.
- He finds Lewis sometimes portrays conversion as both freely chosen and irresistibly effected by God.











