Heading Towards the Fiscal Cliff | Brian Riedl & Richard Hanania
Nov 20, 2023
auto_awesome
Brian Riedl, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, and Richard Hanania discuss the financial future of the US, with a focus on entitlements. They explore the projected fund shortages of Social Security and Medicare, the potential consequences of borrowing money indefinitely, and the lack of seriousness in fiscal policy. The speakers highlight the challenges of raising the payroll tax limit, the inefficiency of Twitter, and the ongoing debt ceiling negotiations.
Social Security and Medicare are projected to run out within the next decade, leading to the need for either massive benefit cuts or increased taxes.
Addressing the entitlement crisis requires a combination of program reforms, middle-class tax increases, and healthcare reforms.
The lack of bipartisan agreement and the fear of losing elections hinder progress in tackling the imminent entitlement crisis.
Deep dives
The Urgent Need to Address Entitlement Programs
There is a growing concern about the long-term viability of entitlement programs such as Social Security and Medicare, driven by factors like the retiring baby boomer population, rising healthcare costs, and increasing interest rates. The deficit continues to rise, and if no action is taken, it could lead to a debt crisis and drastic benefit cuts or increased taxes for the middle class. Despite the urgency of the issue, there is a lack of serious engagement and solutions from both the left and the right, with politicians avoiding necessary reforms due to political reasons.
The Challenging Options to Address the Crisis
When it comes to addressing the entitlement crisis, there are no easy solutions. Merely taxing the rich or cutting certain programs like foreign aid and defense will not be sufficient. Closing the shortfall in Social Security and Medicare requires a combination of reforming these programs, raising middle-class taxes, and implementing healthcare reforms. However, the political climate makes it challenging to touch these programs due to the fear of losing elections. Both Republicans and Democrats shy away from making the difficult decisions needed to tackle the looming crisis.
The Peril of Delaying Reforms
Delaying reforms to entitlement programs only exacerbates the problem. Waiting until the last moment will leave policymakers with limited options and put a heavier burden on the middle class, as raising taxes will become the primary solution. The longer reform is delayed, the more tax-heavy the solution will be. Republicans are reluctant to raise taxes, while Democrats are resistant to touching benefits. The lack of bipartisan agreement and the politicization of the issue hinder the progress needed to address the crisis.
The Potential Escalation of the Crisis
If the current path continues, the United States is headed towards a debt crisis. As interest rates rise and borrowing becomes more challenging, adjustments will have to be made. Drastic benefit cuts, doubling middle-class taxes, or even monetizing the debt by running the printing press are potential outcomes. While no party wants to cut benefits or raise taxes significantly, the limited options and the mounting pressure of the crisis may force policymakers to make tough decisions.
The Need for Awareness and Engagement
It is crucial for the public to be aware of the looming entitlement crisis and for people to engage with their representatives to prioritize fiscal responsibility. This includes understanding the false assumptions surrounding entitlement programs and advocating for comprehensive solutions that address both spending and taxation. By challenging unrealistic promises and demanding serious action, individuals can contribute to the long-term sustainability of our nation's fiscal health.
Brian Riedl is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, focusing on budget, tax, and economic policy. His previous jobs include chief economist to Senator Rob Portman (R-OH), and positions on the Marco Rubio and Mitt Romney presidential campaigns.
He joins the podcast to talk about the financial future of the United States, with a special focus on entitlements. Medicare is projected to run out by 2031, and Social Security only two years later. Because of politicians kicking the can down the road for so long, this will mean that the federal government will at that point have to either implement massive benefit cuts for seniors or significantly raise taxes across the board.
Brian talks about his experience in Washington, the history of negotiations over the debt, and what politicians say when you bring up these facts. We appear to be in an undesirable equilibrium, where everyone’s incentive is to ignore the issues involved, while the status quo is leading us towards disaster. Despite liberals wanting to tax the rich and conservatives calling for a cut to foreign aid and non-entitlement forms of domestic spending, the numbers for such proposals don’t add up. We will either get entitlement spending under control, or become taxed at the level of Europeans.
In one important way, we will actually be worse off than Europe, because their welfare states pay for services and benefits that go to families across a wide section of the population. We are potentially building a US welfare state that will have high taxes primarily to funnel money to the elderly. The fact that older Americans are richer than those who will be supporting them makes the future we are moving towards even more absurd.