Liberalism embodies belief in societies' progress through institutions and individual freedoms.
Liberal values are historically contextual, not universally applicable across all societies.
Balancing liberalism with cultural influences is crucial for societal development.
Deep dives
Francis Fukuyama's Definition of Liberalism
Francis Fukuyama explains that liberalism builds on the idea of human societies as collections of autonomous individuals with equal rights protected by a rule of law. He highlights liberalism's association with modern natural science and its belief in society's potential for improvement through institutions and individual freedoms.
John Gray's Critique of Universal Liberal Values
Philosopher John Gray challenges the notion of a universal momentum toward liberal values, asserting that liberalism emerged as a historical way of life in specific cultural contexts. Gray argues that the collapse of communism was not directly linked to liberalism, emphasizing that individual societies have unique trajectories.
The Complexity of Liberalism and Progress
Both Fukuyama and Gray acknowledge the complexity of liberalism, contrasting views on its perfectibility versus its role in societal progress. Fukuyama suggests that liberalism thrives in economically growing societies, while Gray emphasizes the need to balance liberalism with other cultural and historical influences.
Challenges to Liberalism and Threats from Autocrats
The discussion delves into the challenges posed by autocrats and the emerging threats to liberalism from both the political right and left. There is mention of the importance of free speech and the impact of cultural shifts on liberal values, highlighting potential dangers from rigid ideologies.
The Future of Liberal Societies and Individual Autonomy
The discourse navigates the potential future scenarios for liberal societies, considering the impacts of societal transformations. Gray raises concerns about how the modern emphasis on individuality and self-definition could fragment society, leading to identity struggles and conflicts within liberal frameworks. The dialogue touches on the concept of tolerance and the evolving nature of liberalism amidst changing cultural and political landscapes.
Following the fall of communism in 1989, American political scientist Francis Fukuyama shot to fame with his thesis about the ‘end of history’ – the idea that the entire world was set on a path towards universal liberalism. But 30 years on, liberalism is under attack from both the Right and the Left – and from Vladimir Putin’s Russia. Professor Fukuyama was joined in conversation by John Gray, the British political philosopher, who rejects the idea of a universal momentum towards liberal values and human progress. Despite the view of many that the Russian invasion of Ukraine marks the end of the post-Cold War era, Fukuyama believes that it is a wake-up call for the West to rekindle the spirit of 1989, while Gray holds that the idea that liberalism will ever triumph is a mirage. Chairing the discussion is the journalist, author and broadcaster, Helen Lewis.