The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 3 - Alex Rodriguez stops by The Herd
Oct 7, 2025
Former MLB star Alex Rodriguez joins the discussion, offering insights into the intense pressure facing players like Aaron Judge in New York. He argues that the Yankees must balance roster stability with the need for change to build a championship team. Rodriguez also praises the Dodgers' depth, which allows them to thrive without relying on one superstar. He shares optimism about the Mariners' postseason potential, highlighting their home-field advantage and young talent. The conversation dives into the broader health of baseball today, voicing concerns over future labor disputes.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Manager Is Often Scapegoat For Executive Moves
- Aaron Boone faces relentless criticism despite limited control over lineups and is in a no-win position.
- Alex Rodriguez argues accountability should include executives explaining roster/lineup decisions to absorb heat for outcomes.
Kingdome Memory Frames Manager Styles
- Alex recalled meeting Colin at the Kingdome and referenced Lou Piniella as a different managerial style.
- He used that experience to explain why old-school hard managers may not fit today's player-driven clubhouse.
Moments Matter More Than Seasonal Stats
- Aaron Judge carries outsized pressure in New York that compounds struggles faster than in smaller markets.
- Rodriguez says moments, not season stats, define a player's legacy in Yankee lore.